3 ms·
> Or have their system of governance proportional based on number of slaves (3/5s, electoral college distribution). Uh... you do realize that 3/5 hasn't been t
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
> Or have their system of governance proportional based on number of slaves (3/5s, electoral college distribution).
Uh... you do realize that 3/5 hasn't been true for close to two centuries now? You sound like you're just grasping for something to complain about.
> Most countries are capable of realising and admitted bad things, and working on making them impossible ( see Germany).
We did. See the US Civil War.
> The document is obsolete ( as you said yourself, it literally dates from a different time, a time with kings, slaves, the fastest travel method being a horse or a boat, literacy being rare, etc.) and needs to be rewritten before being torn down.
You've argued that it's old. That doesn't make it obsolete - that's something different.
You sound like people who want to re-write their program in the new shiny language, just because it's new and shiny. That's a terribly wasteful idea. If it's broken (not just old), then fix what's broken.
- sofixa 5y ago> Uh... you do realize that 3/5 hasn't been true for close to two centuries now? You sound like you're just grasping for something to complain about. Isn't the 3/5s still used as the basis for the number of representatives and electoral college members? If not, i'm sorry, i was mistaken. > We did. See the US Civil War. Which then resulted in Jim Crow laws and segregation, which only ended a century after said Civil War, and the effects are still visible today. Furthermore, slavery is still legal as a form of punishment. > You've argued that it's old. That doesn't make it obsolete - that's something different. I mentioned all the things i consider obsolete, like the broken political system. I can add a few more - slavery being legal, an electoral college existing, the current "Equal Rights Amendment" which still hasn't passed, the serious link between religion and government ( swearing on a bible counts for something), plenty of others. The document is obsolete because it is old, doesn't contain things which are the norm in any developed country's constitution ( like equal rights between men and women), and carries significant baggage. It's like saying an old COBOL program, which has many patches for many bugs and many things it did wrong, but kind of functions, is a black box that can't be monitored, etc. needs to be rewritten in a modern language with modern tooling. There are things that are wrong with the old one, and so much so it merits a complete rewrite.
- AnimalMuppet 5y ago> Isn't the 3/5s still used as the basis for the number of representatives and electoral college members? If not, i'm sorry, i was mistaken. No. That was removed, by amendment, right after the Civil War. That language is no longer part of the Constitution. So this gets to the question of what to do with that crufty old COBOL program. How many bugs are you going to introduce by re-writing it? How many interfaces to other programs are you going to break? Sure, it's a pain to patch it - it's difficult and time-consuming. But re-writing it has a lot of downside, even though programmers keep assuming that it will be easy and painless...