4 ms·
I've never gotten the reconciliation of many of these "learn accounting" guides with what it takes to do actual accounting. They seem to make a big deal of cove
by mindslight 5y ago
I've never gotten the reconciliation of many of these "learn accounting" guides with what it takes to do actual accounting. They seem to make a big deal of covering very basic concepts that I would expect anybody with a programming background to pick up in under 10 minutes. The topics covered by these guides are less complex than most APIs.
But when it comes time to do actual accounting, there is a whole host of much more complicated concepts - depreciation, capitalization, tax law, tax law, tax law, etc. And these never seem to be explained in any comprehensive way that would make me think I "know" accounting. Rather it's like the pedagogy is focused on basic math (which people call "accounting"), because you will only learn all of the details with experience.
I even felt this same divide when I tried out Quickbooks, which I had thought was one of the gold standards for small business accounting. I was hoping for something that would walk me through how I needed to categorize expenses, track assets for depreciation, etc. Instead I was greeted with basically a spreadsheet replacement to automate problems I didn't have (eg printing checks at scale).
Am I wildly off base here, or is there something else I'm missing?
Taking a look at the site posted, it does seems to have many chapters with later ones covering advanced topics. But for instance taking a look at the chapter on depreciation, there are still additional details you'd actually need to do your taxes. I can understand how a simpler model helps someone learning this as their "first field", and they'll learn the richer model later. But from the perspective of someone who knows how to program, I'm still left wondering what value there is from reading general guides versus eg directly digging into what tax law forces you to calculate.
- PopAlongKid 5y agore: Quickbooks. It has now basically bifurcated into an online version and a desktop version, with somewhat different features. QB will in fact walk you through an optional setup interview to ask about what your general type of business is (service, retail, etc) and will create a default chart of accounts, which takes care of part of your need (how to categorize expenses). It becomes more complicated when the whole optional layer of "items" used to create invoices and bills gets added in. There is a fixed asset function, but QB is not really designed to calculate depreciation, rather it is normally handled with an annual journal entry based on output from the tax return. It does have some frequent traps for new users, who for example often don't understand "undeposited funds" and end up double-counting their revenue. Or, they don't realize that when they transfer money from say checking to savings, the entry made in one account register is automatically reflected in the other.
- mindslight 5y agoI was using the offline version obviously, in a VM with no network access. I do recall some wizards for setting up accounts, but they weren't applicable to my business. It also didn't feel like such wizards would have changed the UI into operating at a higher level.
- PopAlongKid 5y agoIt may not be useful to you, but I will add that Quickbooks desktop has a "Home" window that includes a fairly detailed flow chart of most small business processes (e.g. send an invoice, pay a bill, make a deposit, run payroll, make a refund, and so on and so on), and the nodes of the flow chart are interactive links to various input and reporting windows in the program.
- mindslight 5y agoYes it seemed like it would be valuable if you need to send lots of invoices, pay lots of bills with checks, make many refunds, etc. Quickbooks gives you a formal process for doing so, easy ability to generate documents, etc. Automating transaction mechanics can certainly facilitate doing accounting later, but it doesn't seem like what I expected from "accounting" as in the stuff you would normally have an "accountant" do. Rather it seemed that you had to set up most of your own accounting (eg defining the data model of all the accounts), and Quickbooks would help you by entering in data for the transactions types it knows about (and you use it for).
- PopAlongKid 5y ago>it would be valuable if you need to send lots of invoices, pay lots of bills That is actually a very valuable function that QB provides, because it enables the ability to view financial reports on either an accrual or cash basis. For tax purposes, your business is required to choose one method of accounting or the other at the start and then generally stick with it forever. For management purposes, you can in QB view your reports at any time using either method, because it's all based on the same underlying transaction data.
- dugmartin 5y agoQuickbooks uses double entry accounting at its core but hides it as single entry accounting (like Quicken) by presenting most UI as entries into registers that represent assets (like the checkbox register or invoices) or liabilities (like bills or credit cards) while hiding owner's equity behind a year-end closing dialog. For example instead of having to learn what accounts to debit and credit when invoicing and then receiving payment from a customer you enter invoices in the invoice UI and receive payments in the receive payments and it takes care of the debits and credits for you. You can use Quickbooks to directly do double entry accounting by entering company journal entries. You (or your bookkeeper/accountant) will do that for more complex transactions that don't have a dedicated UI like, for example, partially returning a damage deposit to a tenant with the remainder covering repairs needed. I took a community college course in Accounting when I was thinking about enrolling in an MBA back in the '90s. You can learn the math in a really short amount of time - it is just basic addition/subtraction. It does take a while to get an intuitive feel as to why some things are debit normal and some are credit normal. Doing a bunch of "T" accounts will bake it into your brain. There are some good graphics here about that (first site I found while Googling) - https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/knowledge/accounting/t-accounts/ https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/knowledge/ac...
- mindslight 5y agoSo these "T accounts" are exactly the kind of thing I'm talking about. Reading that page they just seem to be a visual method to represent negative numbers, explained very verbosely? This seems like it might have been a really valuable invention for someone in 1494 or even 1894. But in 2021 when we're comfortable with defining rich semantic models, it just seems quaint and limiting. Like for instance as shown it leaves out the date, whether the transaction has tax relevance, a link to its corresponding second entry, etc. I know this is apostasy, but even "double entry" itself feels this way to me, compared with say more freeform "tags". Like if you pay an expense for repairs, which may be tax deductible, then it seems the only way to represent that expense in strict double book is to have 2 accounts for (Repairs_Tax, Repairs_Notax). And it gets even worse when federal and state tax differ, or multiple states are involved. Whereas what I really want is for that single transaction to possibly show up in multiple expense categories, which are then later summed for specific reports. Maybe my questions parallel the Lisp curse where arithmetic has gotten so easy I'm brushing off what I perceive to be overdiligent focus on shared mechanics? I just don't see what the traditional framework gets me, compared to how much people focus on it.
- JoiDegn 5y agoI am working on a product led alternative to Quickbooks which does the split between being more user-friendly (i.e. less confusing reconciliation, faster interface, easier to navigate, fewer options, fewer ways to shoot yourself in the foot) but also geared towards power users (keyboard shortcuts, automations, integrations with productivity tools). It's fascination that Quickbooks is the go-to tool for almost everyone doing small business accounting when their product is mediocre in so many ways.