3 ms·
It's probably not quite that black and white. You need business smarts too if you want to succeed. Ion Storm is a good example as it was everything contemporar
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
It's probably not quite that black and white.
You need business smarts too if you want to succeed. Ion Storm is a good example as it was everything contemporary Ubisoft is not. It was a very developer-run shop that out of one office produced critically acclaimed Deus Ex, but at the same time produced flop-of-the-ages Daikatana.
It's a tricky balancing act. You can definitely have too much business influence over the creative process. Ubisoft would never produce a flop like Daikatana, but neither would it produce a gem like Deus Ex.
- speeder 5y agohttps://www.metacritic.com/game/ds/imagine-wedding-designer https://www.metacritic.com/game/ds/imagine-wedding-designer disagrees with you :P Ubisoft is actually good at making crap games. For example they bought a Brazillian studio that was often contracted to do some cool hunting games. Then they forced the studio to pump low-score after low-score NDS games (Wedding Designer was one of them), there was tons of executive meddling, then they said the studio that was crap and closed it down. Thing is, at the time it was literally the best studio in Brazil, and this incident caused some damage to Brazillian games industry :(
- marginalia_nu 5y agoUbisoft crap is another kind of crap compared to Daikatana crap. Ubisoft essentially produces shovelware, from their flagship AAA-titles down to their obscure NDS titles. It's all sure bets with low creative risk, which makes every sense if you are primarily pandering to shareholders.
- Trasmatta 5y agoSome extra context: those two games were made by entirely different teams. Daikatana was built by John Romero's team, and Deus Ex was made by Warren Spector's team. I don't think there was much collaboration or even communication between the teams. Romero just bankrolled Spector, who happened to have quite a bit more experience, and was likely much better suited to the director role.