4 ms·
It'd be interesting, from a neutral-ish, academic, historic, curiosity perspective, to see a civil war / revolution in a developed country with a modern industr
by sofixa 5y ago
It'd be interesting, from a neutral-ish, academic, historic, curiosity perspective, to see a civil war / revolution in a developed country with a modern industrialised military. The resultant mess can get extremely deadly and hard, if not impossible, to resolve.
That being said, i do personally think a revolution in the US has been coming for quite some and is needed to fix the broken political system ( two party model, winner take all, gerrymandering, electoral college, appointed judges, mind boggling fetishisation of an obsolete document, remnants of slavery, to name just a few). I do sincerely hope it happens as bloodlessly as possible.
(I'm currently listening to the Revolutions podcast, specifically about the Russian Revolution and resultant civil war, and i find it fascinating. Living in such historic moments ( like a pandemic) feels weird. You're there while history is being written, and heck, you might be an active participant! A blessing and a curse).
- fennecfoxen 5y agoHow modern and industrialized? Syria is a real country with MiGs and submarines.
- sofixa 5y agoTrue, but i meant a country modern and industrialised on the level of the US or Western Europe. Drones, nuclear weapons, everything digital and stuff more so than MiGs and submarines ( the latter are of somewhat limited use in a civil war, bar denying the other part supplies from overseas)
- notacoward 5y agoThe idea that we're that different than Syria (or many other examples one could name) is just a form of exceptionalism.
- maxerickson 5y agoTurkish drones have seen wide use in Syria. I am not keeping up with the situation, but for instance: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/middle_east/turkey-drones-libya-nagorno-karabakh/2020/11/29/d8c98b96-29de-11eb-9c21-3cc501d0981f_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/middle_east/turkey-dron... https://www.forbes.com/sites/sebastienroblin/2020/03/02/idlib-onslaught-turkish-drones-artillery-and-f-16s-just-destroyed-over-100-armored-vehicles-in-syria-and-downed-two-jets/?sh=7f7305bf6cd3 https://www.forbes.com/sites/sebastienroblin/2020/03/02/idli...
- caeril 5y agoNuclear weapons are 100% irrelevant to a potential civil war in the United States. It's not North vs. South, it's Red vs Blue, and the physical boundaries are impossible to define - the ideologues are far too evenly distributed. Even in the deepest Red areas of the country, an airburst would murder 20-30% of your own side. That's a level of collateral damage that would be unacceptable to either side. Drones could be useful for more surgical actions, but they would be extremely reliant on accurate intelligence, which would be difficult to gather and verify in this type of theater of war. The failures of the US military to hold Afghanistan would be even more magnified at home. I don't think any of our traditional or modern military hardware would be particularly useful in an actual civil war.
- NikolaNovak 5y agoI've been through a civil war in a developed country with modern industrialized military. It's just a curse.
- f154hfds 5y ago> the broken political system ( two party model, winner take all, gerrymandering, electoral college, appointed judges, mind boggling fetishisation of an obsolete document, remnants of slavery, to name just a few) two party model: while the two party model isn't ideal it's not always been as divisive as it is right now since ~2016. There are steps we could take at the state level that would over time make this better. winner take all: Our system is designed to have a relatively powerful head of state while also enforcing severe limitations. The constitution mostly accomplishes this by giving the president the military but not the budget. In principle this is a difficult balance to get right. Too much power to the president and there is a run-away effect where limitations get sidestepped over time. Too little power and the federation eventually breaks apart (imagine Lincoln accepting the confederacy without a fight). gerrymandering: This is also hard to get right. It is indicative of systemic problems that politicians can't reach an agreement that would more universally curb this undemocratic practice but it's easy to condemn these practices and much harder to propose airtight alternative solutions. electoral college: there are pros and cons. The pros are that it works to balance power between population centers and vast rural areas by giving a slight boost to unpopulated areas over the population centers. The cons are obviously that the result of this leads to elections that are slightly off from a 'popular' vote. Feel free to dislike the rule but it is debatable at the very least. Appointed judges: yes they're appointed at the federal level (there's a deep history to this aspect of the three branches of government), but states do it differently. In my area most of my judges by case load are elected officials. obsolete document: again, it's easy to criticize but hard to offer alternatives that would work better. I'm weary of the lazy attempts to tear institutions down while not recognizing their incredible value. Remember this has been the defining document outlining our system of government since King George III. Remnants of slavery: what country doesn't deal with problems stemming from its past sins? How would some sort of revolution help to fix this?
- sofixa 5y agoI'd have to hard disagree. > two party model: while the two party model isn't ideal it's not always been as divisive as it is right now since ~2016. There are steps we could take at the state level that would over time make this better. Is this really the best excuse you have? It hasn't always been this bad? Are there any legitimate reasons to want or keep a two party system? That the people benefiting from it don't want it to change is a very poor excuse, and honestly i can't think of another one. > winner take all: Our system is designed to have a relatively powerful head of state while also enforcing severe limitations. The constitution mostly accomplishes this by giving the president the military but not the budget. In principle this is a difficult balance to get right. Too much power to the president and there is a run-away effect where limitations get sidestepped over time. Too little power and the federation eventually breaks apart (imagine Lincoln accepting the confederacy without a fight) I meant winner of a single election take all, disenfranchising anyone who didn't vote for the winner. E.g. a senator elected with 45% against another candidate with 30% represents only the 45% of the electorate who voted for them, the rest be damned. Obviously that's ridiculously stupid, and makes it so people in areas overwhelmingly disagreeing with them don't even bother voting, and aren't represented by anyone. > gerrymandering It's not that hard to get right, go proportional at a fixed predefined level - like a state. 10 representatives from the state, state-level elections, and the places are proportionally distributed per list/party by percent of votes. > electoral college: there are pros and cons. The pros are that it works to balance power between population centers and vast rural areas by giving a slight boost to unpopulated areas over the population centers. The cons are obviously that the result of this leads to elections that are slightly off from a 'popular' vote. Feel free to dislike the rule but it is debatable at the very least. To stop disenfranchising a part of the population ( rural areas), it drastically disenfranchises the vast majority of the population ( urban areas). Rural areas are already overrepresented by virtue of the fixed number of senators per state. I think that's more than enough, but i agree, it's debatable. However what's not debatable is applying the ridiculously stupid winner take all logic for that. > Judges I'm not saying elected judges are better than appointed by the executive, because both are pretty bad. Popular judges aren't necessarily the best ones. A mixed system whereby other judges, prosecutors and lawyers vote seems better, but that's certainly debatable. > Slavery & constitution Few countries explicitly allow slavery in their constitution. Or have their system of governance proportional based on number of slaves (3/5s, electoral college distribution). Most countries are capable of realising and admitted bad things, and working on making them impossible ( see Germany). The document is obsolete ( as you said yourself, it literally dates from a different time, a time with kings, slaves, the fastest travel method being a horse or a boat, literacy being rare, etc.) and needs to be rewritten before being torn down.