2 ms·
If you switch the word "disruptive" for "likely to have negative externalities", this seems less like two descriptions of opposing philosophies than a single wa
by pessimizer 5y ago
If you switch the word "disruptive" for "likely to have negative externalities", this seems less like two descriptions of opposing philosophies than a single way to lionize the people who support the thing you want to do while caricaturing the people who don't support the thing you want to do.
1) There's nobody who supports the idea of letting any idea be vetoed by anyone. It's not a belief that people have. People have a variety of ideas about how a variety of things should be organized, and who should have standing to keep other people from doing things. This is the entire purpose of political philosophy.
2) It's entirely self-serving and situational; the real distinction is who the negative externalities will affect. "Bulldozers" immediately become "vetoers" when somebody is proposing something that might as a consequence keep them from driving their bulldozers wherever they want.
You might as well classify the world as "players" and "haters." Players are people who let me do what I want, and haters are the people who hate on that.
- marginalia_nu 5y ago> There's nobody who supports the idea of letting any idea be vetoed by anyone. Well, between IBM and Poland-Lithuania, it's not like liberum veto hasn't been tried (with moderate intermediate success and long-term problems as a result).
- com2kid 5y ago> 1) There's nobody who supports the idea of letting any idea be vetoed by anyone. It's not a belief that people have. No, but many existing systems of governance allow (nearly) anyone to raise an objection, thereby delaying the decision making process. If a concerted effort by enough "anyones" is made, a decision can be forcefully delayed long enough that it is essentially halted. For certain processes (e.g. environmental reviews in certain states or municipalities) this entire setup is arguably by design.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThe problem with "likely to have negative externalities" is that if you ask whether something has negative externalities, the answer is always yes. If you carry on breathing, you're emitting CO2 and remain in competition for scarce resources with anyone else who is still alive. If you take your own life you're wasting the resources society invested in your education and causing work for emergency services. Both doing and not doing anything has negative externalities. One of the things that has negative externalities is accounting for negative externalities. It has transaction costs and compliance costs and enforcement costs. This implies that there is a level of negative externalities where the cost of preventing them is more than the cost of incurring them. The key is to catch the breakeven point and not go too far in either direction.
- philips 5y agoThe breathing thing is a pretty poor analogy. The problem with climate change is not living things breathing. It is the insertion of net new carbon into our carbon cycle by digging it out of the ground and burning it.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoNot so. You ate food to make that CO2. If you had buried it underground instead, that carbon would have remained sequestered instead of reentering the atmosphere. It's a good example precisely to show that you can spin anything into a negative externality by comparing it to some possible alternative which is better on some possible metric. Then if you want to show that the other alternative is worse, choose a different metric. No thing exists which is more perfect than all other things across all metrics.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]