3 ms·
> There will not be one single standard of policies that will work for all people, no matter how "democratic" the process to establish the rules are and no matt
by pessimizer 5y ago
> There will not be one single standard of policies that will work for all people, no matter how "democratic" the process to establish the rules are and no matter how good the ideas you think they are.
Are we defining "people" here racially, as a language group, or as the humans who live within the particular borders of an old colony or the territory of a long dead conquerer?
Why is Switzerland the ideal size? Does something about that size reduce the proportion of people at the "periphery of power"?
- rglullis 5y agoIt's not about Switzerland's size. It's about its bottom-up political structure. The cantons hold more political and economical power than the federation. It's so local-first that there are stories of people who were denied Swiss citizenship basically because their neighbors considered the person to be not aligned with the community values. Policies are defined almost at a district level. Comparing with the other "big" countries in Europe, there is no distant bureaucracy enacting laws affecting subjects that are not on the same sphere. The USA was built on the same idea, where states have a lot more direct power than the federal government, but that idea is basically lost because people on both sides of the political spectrum have been pushing for more centralization and federal control.