4 ms·
The project is called Aadhaar, and on it's surface it doesn't seem to be that bad, its a government ID that contains biometric and demographic data and doesn't
by RansomStark 5y ago
The project is called Aadhaar, and on it's surface it doesn't seem to be that bad, its a government ID that contains biometric and demographic data and doesn't seem to contain much more than what is requested of people at the US boarder, or what is contained on most national ID cards in jurisdictions where those exist, and at least the Aadhaar is voluntary, that is the government cannot deny service if someone chooses not to possess an Aadhaar ID. Reading the Wikipedia article also gives hope that the project isn't as bad as it might be.
"On 24 March 2014, the Supreme Court restrained the central government and the UIDAI from sharing data with any third party or agency, whether government or private, without the consent of the Aadhaar-holder in writing." [0]
"On 26 September 2018, the Supreme Court ruled that Section 57 of the Aadhaar Act was unconstitutional, meaning that private entities cannot compel their customers to provide their Aadhaar number as a condition of service to verify their identity, specifically citing requiring it for bank accounts, school admissions, and mobile phone service as examples of unlawful use cases" [0]
I still wouldn't want to have this kind of a system pushed on me, but then I would prefer if the ID chip was removed from my passport...
[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aadhaar#Legality_of_sharing_data_with_law_enforcement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aadhaar#Legality_of_sharing_da...
- tachyons 5y ago> at least the Aadhaar is voluntary It is practically impossible to live in India without aadhar.
- RansomStark 5y agoI've never had the pleasure of visiting India, so have no first hand experience. Could you expand on your point. If the government can't refuse service and third parties cannot ask for the number, how does the lack of an Aadhaar impact everyday life? Just as an aside, I don't doubt what you're saying, I'm just genuinely interested in the mechanics.
- tachyons 5y ago> If the government can't refuse service and third parties cannot ask for the number That is just in theory, you need to have aadhar to pay income tax(not paying tax is a criminal offense), almost all benefits are now getting linked to aadhar. Almost all employers now ask for aadhar details for job.
- mohanmcgeek 5y agoYou need a PAN to file income tax in India. Not AADHAR.
- tachyons 5y agoIncase you missed: https://www.livemint.com/money/personal-finance/income-tax-returns-itr-pan-card-aadhaar-aadhar-linking-1554178613782.html https://www.livemint.com/money/personal-finance/income-tax-r...
- mohanmcgeek 5y agoHyperbole. I can't think of a single place where Aadhar was the only source of identity that can be used
- tachyons 5y agoJust curious, have you managed to submit IT return without aadhar ?