3 ms·
I have only seen it once (or maybe it was a sequel). It had been dubbed into German, which was fine as the kids (we went in a group) were too young to read any
by gumby 5y ago
I have only seen it once (or maybe it was a sequel). It had been dubbed into German, which was fine as the kids (we went in a group) were too young to read anyway.
As soon as it was over I wanted to flee the cinema but the rest of the parents waited for the credits and excitedly commented, “oh, that was John Cleese”. “That was Cameron Diaz”. Etc.
But the film was animated and the voices were not of those people!
Decades later I still don’t understand.
- cyborgx7 5y agoI mean, actors do get assigned localization voices that are used across movies in the German localization industry. So if the voices you associate with those actors are their German localized voices, those are their voices to you.
- netrus 5y agoIn addition to that, usually for animation movies they do the voices first and make the animation to match. For comedy headliners, one might be able to recognize the actor from animated facial expressions, timing etc. I am in no position to judge if that is true for Shrek. (BTW, the German word for fear is Schreck [not a perfect translation, but the same spirit], yet I never made the connection mentioned in the article. Cool!)
- bredren 5y agoIt was. Because Chris Farley was the original voice actor of Shrek. It was to be his big comeback. But despite his amazing talent and kindness it was all too much, and he died before the picture could be completed. https://youtu.be/9zYT5hQR4Q4 https://youtu.be/9zYT5hQR4Q4 Hard to say what kind of shrek we would have had today if he had made it. https://nymag.com/arts/books/reviews/47039/ https://nymag.com/arts/books/reviews/47039/
- AlwaysRock 5y agoWow. That is really interesting. I didnt realize that. Has there been any notable recasting's due to death or contract negotiations or something like that? I could imagine Luke Skywalker sounds drastically different in the third film being a pretty jarring experience.
- NikolaNovak 5y agoI found that dubbing is very popular in some countries, whereas subtitling is preferred in others. I've been brought up with subtitles and have never been able to stomach dubbed movies - whether live or animated, it feels a lot of original character/emotion/nuance is lost; and, a lot of overdubbing overdoes vocal emoting. So I watch original language with subtitles - even though I don't understand the voice, I pick up the original emotion and intent, while the brain processes subtitles to match. My wife has been brought up with dubbing, so initially had aversion to subtitles; she felt her attention was split between text, and following actions/acting. But - after a few movies, she's now a subtitle convert as well - she's seen how much gets lost in dubbing. Of course for kids, this may be a moot point as they cannot read subtitles either way.
- lou1306 5y ago> I have only seen it once (or maybe it was a sequel) Just to be nitpicky, it was 100% a sequel (as John Cleese only appears in those).
- gumby 5y agoOf course he doesn’t actually appear in any of them at all.