3 ms·
I don't think there's a contradiction in your example. "Nobody deserves to be rich" seems to be just a moralistic opinion about individual behavior - and perhap
by noduerme 5y ago
I don't think there's a contradiction in your example. "Nobody deserves to be rich" seems to be just a moralistic opinion about individual behavior - and perhaps, what they do with their wealth. It's not really a policy prescription, in that it's purely negative, i.e. preventing people from getting rich doesn't necessarily have any relationship with preventing other people from being poor. (See: USSR).
But "allowing people to become rich ... benefits everyone in the society" is, however arguable, a policy position and not a negative judgment on personal behavior. It proceeds from the fact that in every society, ever, wealth stratification emerges; and it accepts that the state has an interest in both allowing some accumulation of capital and in preventing a runaway hoarding of wealth.
So I think you could reconcile these views. Both of your statements follow a consistent, demonstrable underlying argument: That without some intervention by the state, too much wealth will accumulate at the top and extreme poverty will reign at the bottom. From that starting point, your views aren't contradictory; you would be on the side of well-regulated markets. You're not stepping into the fantasy lands where either eating the rich or trickling down wealth will cure poverty.