3 ms·
So the CDC lied and now that lie is coming back to bite them when people doubt what they say going forward? And please, Delta was starting to circulate before
by refurb 5y ago
So the CDC lied and now that lie is coming back to bite them when people doubt what they say going forward?
And please, Delta was starting to circulate before the vaccine was widely available outside the US and Europe.
But that’s exactly what I’m talking about. The unvaccinated make a good scapegoat for the failure to properly message.
- supertrope 5y agoIf they promote very cautious behavior (keep sheltering in place, wear masks) people will throw the catch phrase of "Trust the science!" back at them and demand why the vaccine has not solved the pandemic. If they loosen up on recommendations and something bad happens and they have to take a step back people say they are being capricious.
- refurb 5y agoOr they could just be honest and stop claiming a solution they don’t even know will work? It’s classic PR rule #1 - don’t lie because the lie will eventually catch up to you. It’s better to say you don’t know.
- supertrope 5y agoIMO the errors that cost 800,000 Americans their lives were made last year. The President publicly denied the seriousness of the situation. The CDC didn't want to use a foreign test and made their own but they were all contaminated and always read positive. There was minimal contract tracing of travelers. The Surgeon General told Americans not to wear masks saying using masks incorrectly would harm them.
- refurb 5y agoHaven’t most of the deaths happened this year? Sure we may have started off wrong but clearly we could have course corrected? Or are Americans too stupid to understand the risks and trade offs?
- supertrope 5y agoWith exponential growth early decisive action is needed. Isn’t course correction lying? :)
- acdha 5y agoThe problem was that it was politicized hard early on. Now you have roughly a third of the country who’ve been told that public health measures are an unpatriotic plot, and a lot of belligerence had been encouraged. The rhetoric around this made it a very clear party loyalty test and lots of people rose to that challenge. How many people are willing to admit that they were so wrong for the better part of two years and many thousands of people died who wouldn’t have? That’s very close to admitting that those same people weren’t just lying about one thing.
- refurb 5y agoI’ve spent months in 4 different countries since Covid hit and it’s politicized everywhere. Not sure how you can force people to stay at home, kids out of school, then hand out billions in relief (or not in one country) and not have it be political?
- acdha 5y agoI was specifically thinking about the politicization of protection and treatment. The economic impact was definitely always going to be a debate but basic safety measures like masks and vaccination didn’t used to be a strongly partisan issue (think about how American doctors historically leaned Republican for tax reasons). Different countries matter less in the internet era, too. In the English-speaking world, the Murdoch media set the message in the US & UK, of course, but these days that spreads quickly outside of national borders and it was easy to see those messages jump to other language communities on social media. This was especially accelerated by the early recognition of certain risk factors which were compatible with the strong man posturing common to a lot of right-wing ideology.
- fivea 5y ago> I've spent months in 4 different countries since Covid hit and it’s politicized everywhere. There's a world of difference between criticizing a government for imposing a lockdown at 10pm instead of 11pm or enforcing a 80% occupancy limit instead of 50%, and attacking basic public health measures like taking a vaccine based on sheer lunacy and conspiracy theories.