2 ms·
> To me, we can take the Ace of Hearts and the Ace of Spades, shuffle them, and deal them out, face down, one each to Bob and Sally. Bob can go a light year awa
by lmm 5y ago
> To me, we can take the Ace of Hearts and the Ace of Spades, shuffle them, and deal them out, face down, one each to Bob and Sally. Bob can go a light year away. Sally then looks at her card and knows right away, nothing faster than the speed of light needed, what Bob's card is.
> We know all the associated probability distributions for Bob and Sally. And we know that as soon as the cards are dealt what each of Bob and Sally have is determined -- so far unknown but still determined.
Right, so that's a hidden variable theory. But the Bell Inequalities give you a set of measurements that can't be explained by hidden variables - one simpler variation is Conway's "free will theorem": Bob and Alice each have something like 29 envelopes, and if he opens one of several sets of 3, then he will always find two black cards and one white card (and Alice will always find the opposite). But there's no way to "statically" assign black and white cards to envelopes so that all of these sets of 3 have that property. So either which cards are in which envelopes really is undetermined until Bob opens a set of 3, or you somehow know which envelopes Bob is going to open at the point where you're putting the cards in the envelopes.