3 ms·
> The intuition behind this is appealing (that a lack of religion invites a void that is filled by crazier things), but the current evidence seems to indicate t
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
> The intuition behind this is appealing (that a lack of religion invites a void that is filled by crazier things), but the current evidence seems to indicate that this is incorrect. Mainstream religions aren't a "prophylactic" against newer craziness like QAnon.
> In fact, the reality is the opposite. QAnon is most effective in converting people who already believe in Christianity.
I don't think you're looking at the right things. If you'll permit an extended quote from another Scott:
> In high school I took a sociology class, and the teacher talked about how modern society was atomized and there were no real community bonds and so on. And I thought this was dumb. I didn’t live in an atomized society! My family knew our next-door neighbors, and we’d even been over at their house once for dinner. There was a Community Center a few blocks away, and when I was a kid I would go there a couple of times a year for some kind of Neighborhood Art Night. Sometimes my mother volunteered at my school, and my dad was too busy to volunteer but probably would have if he could. We weren’t devoid of community at all.
> And then three things happened. Number one, I read some good anthropology about primitive and medieval societies, which actually described pre-atomized life and the way that there was barely even an individual identity and the community determined everything you ever did. Number two, I spent a little time in an honest-to-goodness Third World village and saw a little of what life was like there. And number three, I got involved in some good subcultures – including Bay Area rationality – which were slightly but noticeably less atomized than the neighborhood where I grew up. I realized that I’d mistaken the existent-but-weak forms of community in my suburban neighborhood for the really-strong forms of community that people complaining about atomization say we’re missing, because I had so little experience with the latter I couldn’t even imagine them.
( https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/11/07/concept-shaped-holes-can-be-impossible-to-notice/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/11/07/concept-shaped-holes-c... )
You're looking at the void that people are trying to fill with newer, more satisfying religions, calling that void "mainstream religion", and then saying that mainstream religion doesn't block the adoption of newer more virulent religions. But mainstream religion in the United States died a long time ago. The people you're "disagreeing" with are looking at the same void, calling it a void, and complaining that there's nothing there to block the adoption of maladaptive beliefs. Which is the same complaint that you're making.