81 ms·
Can we please get rid of the DevOps hype train? What gets completely ignored is that there is a reason that sysops has been a specialized role for decades. How
by mschuster91 5y ago
Can we please get rid of the DevOps hype train?
What gets completely ignored is that there is a reason that sysops has been a specialized role for decades. How often do we get threads here that people get their AWS accounts hijacked because of some credential leak (e.g. access keys in frontend builds), extreme expenses due to stupid autoscaling settings combined with a DoS attack or content leaks out of insecure s3 buckets? Or how much money gets wasted because clueless "devops" developers think that failsafe redundancy for their tiny PHP app is configuring a bunch of x2large instances and putting ELB in front of it instead of either going with lambda functions in the first place or at the very least use small instances and sensible autoscaling.
Or ffs just take gitlab ci pipelines. Nearly every time when taking over a project or hopping in to consult I see utter fucking bullshit written by people who don't have any idea what the fuck they are doing. Yeah, your build takes 10 minutes because you don't use any cache anywhere and you don't use Nexus or any other form of repository cache. And ffs no you should not push your application image to public Dockerhub because you have no idea that Gitlab has its own registry - and no, "I read it on some 'getting started' guide for <insert JS framework here>' ain't an excuse either. People get barely trained in the technology they use, most JS frameworks (and fwiw, Gitlab and Github CI themselves!) are young enough that it's impossible to get senior people for them, and the stuff that ships for "CI templates" there is atrocious.
The amount of knowledge required to securely operate any kind of hosting or development operation is immense, and acting like developers should also shoulder the role of unix sysadmin, IT security staff and cloud configurations is extremely ignorant - not to mention only half of the developers know more than "ls/cd/rm" on the command line, less if they are Windows developers.
I do see value in "devops" as in "a person primarily focused on operating infrastructure, but with enough capability to troubleshoot production issues in applications", but devops as in "save money for actually qualified ops staff" is irresponsible penny pinching.
- g051051 5y agoGreat to see someone else saying this for a change. "Dev" and "Ops" are different skill sets with some potential overlap, but not 100%. Organizations I've been in have never done the "throw it over the wall" thing, either. Dev and Ops are partners, and treating things any other way is a recipe for failure.
- darepublic 5y agoAccess keys on frontend is the fault of the frontend developer or culture
- mschuster91 5y agoThere will always be irresponsible or junior people, the problem is that AWS allows extremely unsafe things in the first place. Normal hosters wouldn't even open internal infra like DB instances, mail relays or storage up to the Internet, AWS by default doesn't even firewall their internal stuff off and thinks, as long as you have the right credentials, you can't be wrong, even if the IP is not from eu-central-1 but some dial-up in Mexico any more. S3 and SES have mind-bogglingly insecure defaults, and it is hard to wall off your SES credentials enough that they're useless to an attacker who has managed to exfiltrate them (and that one is easy enough, all an attacker needs is a vulnerable log4j and the dubious "best practice" of passing credentials via environment variables). It is so incredibly easy to mess up on AWS it hurts. AWS is a gun shop that not just sells handguns but nuclear armed bomber jets to anyone presenting a credit card. No knowledge checks, training, nothing required, and you have the firepower of all of AWS on your hands.
- atomicfiredoll 5y agoThis. I think that today the barrier to entry is low enough that, especially in small companies, developers with little knowledge of the space can get a basic CI system or production deployment going. And, the company is more than happy to let them instead of hiring somebody specializing in the area. This seems to really blow up if it goes unaddressed as the team/product grows. I've watched at least one company burn time on the same issues for years because instead of acknowledging the need for and empowering people with distinct skillsets or knowledge, they're content to let developers bumble through the process of learning and reinventing the wheel over and over in the margins. That's if they can even get the developers on growing and siloed teams to communicate with one another at all. There needs to be experienced leadership somewhere. Developers should have more responsibility over their apps and what they're putting in to production. But, it's unfair an inefficient to expect all but a few will ever even have time to become skilled practitioners in these areas. Especially while already keeping up with their normal duties. Now not just tech debit, but foundational infrastructure can be pushed aside by the drive for new/more features. For the foreseeable future it seems like the trend of tasking devs with so much of this work will result in engineering teams continuously, wastefully toiling over fractured infrastructure built by novices. (Maybe someday the tools will actually allow for developers to take this one with limited knowledge/resources, though.)