3 ms·
> there isn't much more to what the government should subsidize, for the same reason the government shouldn't provide universal free yacht moorings Let's be aw
by wolverine876 5y ago
> there isn't much more to what the government should subsidize, for the same reason the government shouldn't provide universal free yacht moorings
Let's be aware of our bias toward our own knowledge and work.
Knowledge of humanities and social sciences is not a luxury; it addresses almost all the critical issues in society - freedom, peace, war, prosperity, politics, economics, human nature through which it all happens, communication, conflict, power, democracy, capitalism, communism, etc. etc. All things more important than whatever most of us do.
- tptacek 5y agoA post-secondary 4-year education in the humanities is a luxury almost by definition, since it is not available to a substantial portion of the population (including many who attend 4-year college!), and wouldn't be even if tuition were free. The arts are important too, but owning a Renoir is still a luxury. I reject the argument that taking 4 years of courses on "communication, conflict, power, democracy, capitalism, communism, etc" is "more important" than "whatever most of us do", and I reject it for a bunch of reasons, not just the obvious one that taking a class on power is not the same thing is engaging with power.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoWhich is why lawyers and media operators run the country. While you're rejecting the argument, they're using it against you. And you're being persuaded by them. Successfully. While still being convinced that the status quo isn't just the best of all possible worlds, everything you believe about it is your own idea.
- tptacek 5y agoI have no idea what you're trying to say here. I can't even tell if you're agreeing with me or disagreeing with me.
- wolverine876 5y agoPerhaps cutting to the chase: I'm aware that it's popular to discount those issues and education in those areas, but I think that just a little critical thought shows that the situation is quite the opposite, and on a very serious, urgent level: The issues are tearing apart our society and world, and it doesn't hold any water to say that we do not need to study these very difficult issues (we can see how human society has performed through most of history) and that we won't benefit from all the prior and contemporary knowledge in humanity. Why wouldn't you study what the ancient Greeks, Enlightenment thinkers, etc. have to say about it, and study it now, urgently? Addressing some details, in case the paragraph above misunderstands you, thought I think these are a bit too much in the weeds: > A post-secondary 4-year education in the humanities is a luxury almost by definition, since it is not available to a substantial portion of the population (including many who attend 4-year college!) Availability doesn't define luxury. When food is unavailable to most of the population, it still isn't a luxury. But we're not here to define words; I think the core issue is that, IMHO, such issues in the liberal arts are critical to the individuals and to our society. > 4 years of courses on "communication, conflict, power, democracy, capitalism, communism, etc" Reducing essential knowledge on these issues to just "courses" is like reducing knowledge about food supply to 'courses'. It's not 'courses', obviously, any more than nuclear weapons nonproliferation agreements are 'paper'. The idea that you know without studying is hard to fathom (beyond the popular trend) - how does the knowledge get into your head? Should we all rediscover through personal experience the most brilliant in human history have discoverd over billions of lifetimes? It seems a bit unlikley and inefficient.
- tptacek 5y agoThe premise of your response is that these challenges we face in our culture and politics are best addressed by a 4-year liberal arts education. I reject this argument as well, and again for a multiplicity of reasons, not least that it implies that only a subset of people who hold degrees are qualified to engage with society. I don't think you mean to belittle the skilled trades (which, ultimately, the industry most of us work in is destined to join) the way you're doing here. But it might be worth reflecting on how what you're saying might be coming across.