4 ms·
> People who support lockdowns aren't interested in facts; their viewpoints are shaped by marketing. Sweeping generalizations aren't really adding to the discu
by paulryanrogers 5y ago
> People who support lockdowns aren't interested in facts; their viewpoints are shaped by marketing.
Sweeping generalizations aren't really adding to the discussion here. Please assume the best of others. We're all trying to find the best way forward with incomplete information. And tying ideas too closely to ones identity, or that of others, won't help us adapt as more evidence come to light.
- throwaway_2009 5y agoStrongly disagree. People who call for authoritarian measures such as using force in order to prevent people from leaving their homes, from associating with friends and family, and from engaging in business, should not have the best assumed of them. They have malicious intentions a priori because they treat controlling others with the same level of discipline as they would choosing which flavour of jam to put on their toast in the morning. They are enemies of freedom and democracy; I'd argue they are truly terrorists, in that they seek to use fear and terror to control others' behaviours. People who _explain and convince_ are interested in what you call discussion. People who use force against you unless you do exactly what they tell you are not engaging in discussion, they're engaging in an attempt at control.
- paulryanrogers 5y ago> They have malicious intentions a priori because they treat controlling others with the same level of discipline as they would choosing which flavour of jam to put on their toast in the morning. Not everyone advocating lockdowns is necessarily so flippant about it. Some consider the costs carefully. Please keep in mind that hospitals were being overwhelmed long before vaccines were available. (FWIW I'm not defending absolute lockdowns since going outside with moderate distancing appears to have been safe at every stage of this phenomenon.)
- throwaway_2009 5y agoIf you want to lockdown, you can lockdown, and now you are safe. You don't need others to do so, the virus does not travel through windows and walls. As such the stance is definitionally illogical which makes it flippant - it falls apart under even mild scrutiny. I've seen about a billion variations on it now, it just gets boring to bat them off. e.g. "if the healthcare system is overwhelmed, you'll die in a minor car crash, so don't go outside, then you won't drive your car or stand near cars, then you can't die in a minor car crash anyway, err... but lockdown though!". It's tautologically broken. The basic premise is of "not doing X, in order to not do X".
- paulryanrogers 5y agoPeople still need emergency rooms. If those are overwhelmed then anyone needing emergency care will suffer.
- throwaway_2009 5y agoI've addressed this in my comment already. If we don't lock down and you break your leg, you may not get medical attention. So let's lock down so that it's impossible to break your leg. I'm totally happy to accept that contracting coronavirus could be triaged lower than acute chronic conditions, heart attacks, etc, that's an interesting debate to have because healthcare is scarce and therefore an ordering _must_ be chosen. What makes no sense is just flinging our hands up and saying "well, stop the world for everyone instead".
- dexen 5y ago>Sweeping generalizations aren't really adding to the discussion here That sentiment fits individualist views and policies, where it behooves us to hear out individuals and consider them on their individual merits. However the view and policy discussed (limitations on individuals for common good) is explicitly a collectivist view and policy. Applying a sweeping generalization to a collectivist view and policy is fit and proper by the very nature of collectivism. Edit: corrected a typo from "individuals" to "individualist".
- paulryanrogers 5y agoIt is possible that people who support(ed) lockdowns are not motivated solely by marketing. The original quote calls out people, not views.
- throwaway_2009 5y agoI disagree. It is not possible because it is not possible to arrive at the stance via logic. If not for the marketing campaign; certainly if not for the "original sin" of Italy's lockdown; we wouldn't even be speaking about this. If coronavirus were highly transmissible ebola it would make sense. It's just not, most of us know tens or hundreds of people who've had it at this point (the UK has a _confirmed_ case rate of over 17%).
- paulryanrogers 5y agoIt's illogical to consider lockdowns when hospitals are overwhelmed by a highly contagious respiratory disease?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- astrange 5y agoThe original “lockdowns” were literally good for some businesses. Conventions and restaurants would have failed (they can’t survive on 10% attendance) but can’t get out of their vendor contracts without the government canceling for them.