4 ms·
> GNOME are the bad guys Just because you disagree with them, it doesn't make them the "bad guys".
by sph 5y ago
> GNOME are the bad guys
Just because you disagree with them, it doesn't make them the "bad guys".
- jrm4 5y agoRight. What actually makes them the bad guys is that they parlayed the goodwill of the original GNOME (2 and prior) which was very open to change and community contribution into the restrictive community hostile thing that it is today. I don't mind that it exists, but they should have changed the name and been more clear about the direction. And should just be less obnoxious all around.
- spindle 5y agoGood point which I hadn't thought of. I really like GNOME 4 for my own workflow, but it doesn't have much in common with GNOME 2.
- pantalaimon 5y agoMATE is carrying on the torch
- _2paq 5y agoThey're making their desktop environment and apps into a walled garden on a platform like Linux. Most GTK4 apps won't be usable outside the intended desktop environment for which they're built. They also engage in carefully crafted doublespeak when it comes to things like extensions and user choice regarding configuration. Call it what you want but they certainly don't intend to play nice with anyone and have adopted the approach of "my way or the highway". Perhaps they're emboldened by all the corporate backing they have from Red Hat and SUSE. They also have the advantage of being the default DE on most distros. Hell, even distros like NixOS encourage users to use GNOME, which is absolutely insane when you think about it.
- mechanical_bear 5y agoI don’t know the intricacies of the politics at play here, so could you explain why this is “insane”?
- _2paq 5y agoI guess this is just my opinion but NixOS is probably the most esoteric Linux distribution I've used. Anyone who intends to use NixOS comfortably probably isn't apprehensive about configuration and customization, things which are the antithesis of everything GNOME stands for. I fail to see why GNOME, or any DE for that matter, is something that should be recommended by a distribution like NixOS.
- SkyMarshal 5y agoBeing the default and thereby “recommended” desktop in NixOS a lot different than in other distro’s. In other distro’s, to get a non-default desktop, you have to download a whole different distro “spin”, like Kubuntu. Or add the new desktop packages and manually configure them all. With NixOS you use the same install image, and just change two or three lines in the master configuration.nix file, and re/build. You can change back and forth between DE’s that use different window managers with a reboot, or between DE’s that use the same window manager with a relog [3]. Most the major desktops are supported in NixOS [1][2]. Gnome being the default means little, is easy to change should NixOS community ever form a consensus about changing the default (say in response to Gnome crossing some line), and is easy for end users to change any time. —— # Gnome services.xserver.enable = true; services.xserver.displayManager.gdm.enable = true; services.xserver.desktopManager.gnome.enable = true; —— # KDE services.xserver.enable = true; services.xserver.displayManager.sddm.enable = true; services.xserver.desktopManager.plasma5.enable = true; —— [1]:More info: https://nixos.org/manual/nixos/stable/index.html#sec-x11 https://nixos.org/manual/nixos/stable/index.html#sec-x11 [2]:Supported desktops: https://search.nixos.org/options?channel=21.11&from=0&size=50&sort=relevance&type=packages&query=DesktopManager https://search.nixos.org/options?channel=21.11&from=0&size=5... [3]:https://www.reddit.com/r/NixOS/comments/otnfq6/i3_or_sway_why_not_both_how_to_have_duel_window/ https://www.reddit.com/r/NixOS/comments/otnfq6/i3_or_sway_wh...
- smoldesu 5y agoI would agree if a. Their development team was more professional (locking threads when feedback starts coming in, making offhand derogatory comments about people's reading comprehension skills, trying to minimize serious problems to avoid dealing with merge requests/more work, blaming downstream actors like PopOS! for simply using their software and disagreeing with their ethos, etc.) b. They used their funding to actually fix issues (GTK4 still has text rendering issues. 8 months later. Insert obligatory "thumbnail file picker" comment here) c. They didn't regress features that previously worked (No more extensions, no more desktop tweaks, overall fewer settings in new releases, design upgrades that are decidedly opinionated) d. They didn't treat their opinions as gospel (eg. encouraging Flatpak-or-die culture when Flatpak itself is still in it's infancy and wildly unstable, going out of their way to obfuscate theming interfaces, having "one guy" come up with a new design for something and implementing it before the community decides if it's something they want) Yeah, I think I am comfortable calling them "the bad guys" in the current landscape of Linux. GTK's team is still fine (barely) but the overall effort to combine the two, add middleware like libadwaita, move fast and break things, and blame it on the user when things stop working is just getting to be asinine. They can have a vision if they want, but it shouldn't have to come at the expanse of the rest of the community. That's how you burn goodwill.
- axiolite 5y ago> GTK's team is still fine (barely) Really? Isn't GTK where the CSD (client side decoration) is being forced onto every app, with no way to use native/normal window manager borders? It seems rather widely despised: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16241923 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16241923 https://old.reddit.com/r/xfce/comments/lcj7cq/why_is_csd_bad/ https://old.reddit.com/r/xfce/comments/lcj7cq/why_is_csd_bad...
- phkahler 5y agoYeah, that goes against everything Wayland.
- smoldesu 5y agoThat's more of a GNOME effort, if I'm being honest. It's a feature that's provided via GTK's libraries, but the whole "we're going to add CSD and you're not going to do anything about it" has been more of a GNOME sentiment[0]. [0] https://blogs.gnome.org/tbernard/2018/01/26/csd-initiative/ https://blogs.gnome.org/tbernard/2018/01/26/csd-initiative/
- simion314 5y ago>Just because you disagree with them, it doesn't make them the "bad guys". I was replying on the consistency topic. some projects offer the user a consistent experience by offering both Qt/GTK support and others don't care and would rather force their branding on you.
- bayindirh 5y ago> Just because you disagree with them, it doesn't make them the "bad guys". Since the KDE 3.5.x days, it's always KDE guys who try to build corresponding GTK themes of the themes they default on the corresponding release, or build corresponding Qt themes of the GTK themes put forward as default by the GNOME guys. Moreover, there are always ways to make GNOME subsystems work well on KDE systems, and KDE guys always make sure that the standards they propose work with the GNOME without much hassle. Also, KDE guys put forward cross-DE ways to make user experience better (XDG base folder specification, for example). OTOH, GNOME people sit on their high thrones like they're the only game in town. I respect them deeply, but I can't appreciate them just because they auto-generated their JS introspection layer from C code automatically, but didn't bother to write any documentation, because you can try it all in the built-in JS console. I have a couple of more, lower level stories with them, which caused a lot of all-nighters and project postponements, but that's for another comment. Their attitude is not helpful.
- OOPMan 5y agoThey may not be bad people, but their GUI framework is pretty bad.