4 ms·
> it's that we seem to be past the peak of what they can solve There's no peak to preventing a fixed percentage of deaths. It's fixed. > and yet keep putting
by stavros 5y ago
> it's that we seem to be past the peak of what they can solve
There's no peak to preventing a fixed percentage of deaths. It's fixed.
> and yet keep putting all our eggs in that basket.
As far as I'm aware, we haven't stopped all other research, so that would be false.
> How do the unvaccinated keep 'filling up' hospitals if vaccines reduce spread and there's 80-90%+ double-dose coverage?
Because 2% of 10% of an entire country is still a big number.
- headsoup 5y agoBut that 2% of 10% are not standing in a line all holding hands. It's clear the vaccinated are readily spreading the disease around and yet the reward is greater freedom for them to spread it? Why do we not still care for the unvaccinated regardless of their reasons or situations for being so? The vaccine is clearly not protecting that group (the original reason for mandates), and 'preventing deaths' vs the unknowns around long term vaccine outcomes (we're all just assuming nothing serious at present) and the increases in stresses and illnesses driven from lockdown, restrictions and mandates are creating a toll that we seem happy to assume is always less than the direct covid toll and therefore acceptable.
- stavros 5y ago> It's clear the vaccinated are readily spreading the disease around and yet the reward is greater freedom for them to spread it? Why do we not still care for the unvaccinated regardless of their reasons or situations for being so? Because they chose not to be vaccinated. Why should I limit myself when I have a very small risk after vaccination to protect someone who chose not to be vaccinated, for whatever reason? > The vaccine is clearly not protecting that group And that is their choice. What more is there to discuss?
- headsoup 5y agoBecause they're human and you shouldn't pretend to assume you know their motives or circumstances. Should I decide all those in religious minorities deserve whatever comes to them because they choose not to follow the major religion? Should I decide obese people deserve no support or care because they 'choose' an unhealthy diet? Let's not turn into horrible human beings just because we feel righteous. Righteousness has a habit of causing horrendous suffering.
- stavros 5y ago> Should I decide all those in religious minorities deserve whatever comes to them because they choose not to follow the major religion? In what way is this related to "other people shouldn't be inconvenienced to protect you from the choices you have made"? > Should I decide obese people deserve no support or care because they 'choose' an unhealthy diet? All these examples are so irrelevant that it feels like you're doing it in bad faith. We're not talking about what unvaccinated people should do. We're talking about what vaccinated people should do, and vaccinated people are under no obligation to limit themselves to protect unvaccinated people. If you want to be unvaccinated, fine. I'm not going to go into lockdown so you don't die, though. Risking it is your choice.
- headsoup 5y ago> In what way is this related to "other people shouldn't be inconvenienced to protect you from the choices you have made"? Who is inconvenienced? And should I feel 'inconvenienced' by those going to hospital because of vaccine adverse events? For instance, just for Pfizer in the EU, there are 640K events reported as of now [1], with ~70K of those for Blood & lymphatic system or cardiac disorders. Now these may not all be specific to Covid and not all hospitalisations, but there's certainly some 'inconvenience' to others here, no? Or is there some lower limit of 'inconvenience?' You might also observe that a large number of adverse events are occurring in the 18-64 group, one that is of much lower risk of covid hospitalisation/death in the first place. But wouldn't want to inconvenience you with lockdowns now would we! How frustrating! Better let you out so you can go give some unvaccinated people covid instead hmm? Sorry for the snark but what a selfish attitude. [1] https://dap.ema.europa.eu/analytics/saw.dll?PortalPages https://dap.ema.europa.eu/analytics/saw.dll?PortalPages
- stavros 5y ago> Who is inconvenienced? Vaccinated people. I feel like you aren't following the debate. > And should I feel 'inconvenienced' by those going to hospital because of vaccine adverse events? No, why would you? > Wouldn't want to inconvenience you with lockdowns now would we! How frustrating! Better let you out so you can go give some unvaccinated people covid instead hmm? Sorry for the snark but what a selfish attitude. Yeah if you think "you better stay inside so I don't get COVID because I don't want to get vaccinated" is a reasonable stance, this won't go anywhere. I even completely fail to fathom how "you should limit your own liberty to protect me from my choices" is remotely acceptable, let alone thinking that somebody not doing that is selfish. You can either get vaccinated and go out, or not get vaccinated and stay in. How is it at all reasonable to tell me what to do because you don't want to get vaccinated? You're basically saying "everybody else needs to stop driving because I like walking in the street instead of the sidewalk, how selfish of you to still want to drive!".