4 ms·
Last time I checked, invaccinated patients were vastly over repredented in hospitalization and ICU occupation. No indication, but hard facts. If vaccines preve
by hef19898 5y ago
Last time I checked, invaccinated patients were vastly over repredented in hospitalization and ICU occupation. No indication, but hard facts.
If vaccines prevent serious cases and hospitalization for a large percentage of people, and they do, we would be all good if vaccination rates reach sufficient levels. Until they do, the very limited ICU capacity will be taken up overpropertionally unvaccinated. And we will continue to have problems.
- headsoup 5y agoWhat's a sufficient level then? It was once 70%, then 80, then 90. Now we have places pushing 95 and that's still not enough? Perhaps we should be paying a bit closer attention to what the vaccines aren't doing.
- hef19898 5y agoNo idea what a sufficient level is, Delta, Omicron and all that considered. Also, I am not into pandemic modelling. Since I don't necessarily care where the level right now is, peiple can always look up the latest papers and studies in that topic.
- dzhiurgis 5y agoNZ has 95% rate and just got first omicron cases few days in strict quarantine. Will see how it will go.
- hef19898 5y agoWhat a sufficient level is also depends on the goal: Eradicting Covid would require higher rates then just turning into a less serious endemic virus. Personally I think eradication is impossible by now.
- refurb 5y agoSingapore hit 90%+ vaccination (eligible) a month ago and just got over a raging wave of Delta infections.
- fsh 5y ago100% would be ideal. It seems to impossible to achieve herd immunity against COVID (whether by vaccination or by immunity due to infection), so everyone will get it eventually. The more are vaccinated, the lower the load on the healthcare system will be.
- headsoup 5y ago100% is only an ideal if we don't really believe anything less will work... Don't we want some sort of control group to remain for these vaccines that don't formally conclude their trials for a couple of years yet? Or is everyone just 100% convinced that nothing could possibly go wrong at this point? That would be proper scientific diligence.
- fsh 5y agoThis is about a medical intervention, not about a scientific study. Vaccine adverse events are usually evaluated by comparing with background rates from previous studies. Control groups are used in randomized control trials and are probably mostly worthless without randomization.
- headsoup 5y agoExcept the trials are still underway, so yes, it is about scientific study. And proper diligence and reporting is critical for such a significant experiment, wouldn't you think?
- marvin 5y ago> Or is everyone just 100% convinced that nothing could possibly go wrong at this point What would be an example of something going wrong? Are you thinking that a sub-optimal outcome might occur ("the pandemic lasted 4 months longer than it had to") or that 80% of the people vaccinated drop dead in 2025? The first case would be an unfortunate case of the best attempt of a decision made on uncertain data turning out to be incorrect in retrospect. In the latter case, civilization is still protected as many people chose not to get vaccinated.
- usrusr 5y agoDelta and Omicron are just so much "faster" than what we encountered before. Thankfully the general working principle of the brakes (vaccines) seems to be mostly unaffected by them, but we have to press them harder. What the vaccines are not doing: make it 2019 again.
- marvin 5y agoThis will eventually blow over. People getting infected with a variant that the vaccine does not prevent infection against, will still develop their immune reaction for that variant. At some point in the future there will once again be a balance between the collective immune response and the transmissability of the virus. The vaccines available right now are still obviously the best measure we have to make getting to that point less painful, as they reduce hospitalizations dramatically. It's pretty obvious that e.g. if a 50% vaccination rate leaves the ICU at 10x capacity during an unmitigated outbreak, a 90% vaccination rate would be preferable even if it doesn't prevent the need for quarantine measures. This means that contact-reducing measures don't have to be as severe while the outbreak is happening.