4 ms·
The article makes a very strange assertion: That $5 trillion dollars is not money invested in building roads, schools, and other long-term projects, but is dir
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
The article makes a very strange assertion:
That $5 trillion dollars is not money invested in building roads, schools, and other long-term projects, but is directly transferred from the American economy to the personal accounts of bank executives and employees.
What does the author believe the bank executives and employees do with that money? Some of it is spent on consumption, but most bank executives consume a far smaller portion of their income than anyone else. [1]
Whatever they don't consume is reinvested in the economy.
[1] If you disagree with this claim, then it logically follows that the best form of Keynesian stimulus is tax cuts for bank executives.
- exit 15y agoif bank executives don't consume a smaller portion of their income than anyone else, it follows that the best form of keynesian stimulus is tax cuts for those executives?
- rvkennedy 15y agoBut they do. Because unlike most people, bank executives don't spend most of what they earn on housing, clothing and feeding their families. Even in the best of times, the rich spend less of their income than the others. Right now, they're spending even less than usual, particularly in terms of investment, because of the bleak economic outlook.
- exit 15y agoyes. i agree. i don't follow the argument i was reply to at all.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThe purpose of Keynesian stimulus is to stimulate spending. Most proponents of Keynesian policies oppose directing stimulus to the rich people on the theory that rich people spend the smallest fraction of their income (i.e., they save the most).
- exit 15y agoi don't see how that shows that "the best" form of stimulus would be to lower their taxes.
- danssig 15y agoHe's saying that if the rich are spending more of their money in the economy then we should be giving them even more tax breaks so they could spend even more in the economy. Probably the reason you didn't get what he meant was because it's utterly nonsensical.
- aarghh 15y agoYou make the assumption that their re-investment is necessarily in the US economy.
- jacques_chester 15y agoYou are apparently making the assumption that economies are autarkic silos. edit: 'k' not 'ch'.
- ScottBurson 15y agoEven supposing (as aarghh points out) that the unconsumed money is reinvested in the US economy, I think it's important to ask, what part of that economy? I would expect most of it goes back into the financial services industry -- banks, hedge funds, etc. I think we as a society have to deal with the fact that the financial services industry is more and more about extracting wealth from the rest of the economy and that it is producing less and less of real value relative to its profits.
- jacques_chester 15y agoAnd what is 'real value'?
- dssffefef 15y agoare you stupid or retarded ?
- jacques_chester 15y agoNeither. Many an economic theory has foundered and sunk on the rock of objective value, no matter how defined. But somebody may yet prove the economists wrong. So the first step in any discussion of the grandparent post must be to work out what he meant by 'real value'. What is it? How is it recognised? By whom?
- oh_no_my_eyes 15y agolet's start with the basics. are they creating real value if they destroy the prosperity of mankind through a complete lack of understanding their own alchemy? probably not.
- jacques_chester 15y agoThis still avoids the question. You ask whether they create 'real value' without defining what 'real value' is.
- ars 15y agoDid he really say that $5 trillion dollars went into the pockets of bank executives? Is he aware that there is about $10 trillion dollars of money in the entire US? (M2 and lower money supply.) So basically the personal accounts of bankers has half of all the money in the US? Are we sure this isn't an Austin Powers movie?
- kul 15y agocumulatively
- jamieb 15y agoWhatever they don't consume is reinvested in the economy. You'd be forgiven for saying that because thats always been the case. Until 2009. http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/EXCRESNS http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/EXCRESNS The banks don't spend the money, they stuff it in the Fed. The bankers dont spend the money (as you point out), they put it in bank, or in treasuries, or they buy stock (and then the seller puts it in a bank, or in treasuries, or they buy stock). Or they pay off some debt. Sometimes, rarely, the money is invested in a small company that actually creates jobs. However, if I was rich and didn't give a shit about my fellow citizens, I'd be investing in emerging economies, not the USA. Any evidence bankers are like that? New jobs come from small businesses. $5t would jump start a lot of small businesses. The irony is that if that $5t were invested in small businesses etc, the bankers would probably be making just as much if not more.
- waterlesscloud 15y agoWhat are Treasuries, exactly?
- oh_no_my_eyes 15y agoare you asking for an explanation? these are treasuries: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Treasury_security http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Treasury_security
- trevelyan 15y agoStrange circular reasoning. Why should taxpayers pay the banks to lend them money at interest? The Fed has been doing this as a backhanded way of recapitalizing the financial sector (lending money at extremely low rates which banks then pour into liquid but higher-paying investments like Treasuries along with more speculative leveraged plays against the USD). It isn't hard for players with privileged access to capital to print money in this situation, and this is what makes the exorbitant compensation rankle: if the unstated justification for the money pump is to recapitalize the financial sector the constant hemorrhaging of assets on personnel compensation is parasitic and abusive.
- 15y ago
- halad 15y agoThe financial system appears to be an instrument of theft. Regardless of what percentages of their incomes bankers invest and consume, this doesn't change the fact that there is an ongoing and significant transfer of wealth from the many to the few. A transfer that defies market outcomes because over the long terms banks only make losses. Rolling Stone once portrayed a major investment bank as a giant "Vampire Squid". Maybe they were onto something.
- tpatke 15y agoYou should read The Economics of Innocent Fraud. http://www.amazon.co.uk/Economics-Innocent-Fraud-Pocket-Penguins/dp/0141023015 http://www.amazon.co.uk/Economics-Innocent-Fraud-Pocket-Peng... >Whatever they don't consume is reinvested in the economy. This is true of all financial transactions. The question is, are resources being allocated efficiently? As the authors state - that 5 trillion is not going to build schools or hospitals.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoAs the authors state - that 5 trillion is not going to build schools or hospitals. It's almost certain that some chunk of it is being spent on (for-profit) hospitals and schools. But you are correct - some it is is spent on automotive manufacturing, telecom infrastructure, heavy equipment producers, sporting goods, etc. Is there some reason to believe that schools and hospitals is a better use of the money than these other projects?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- gavanwoolery 15y agoYou are almost right but you are neglecting a major factor: the uneven distribution of wealth. Simple example: Lets say I make 100k but 30k goes to "taxes", meant to be spent on public utilities that (more or less) benefit me, such as roads, schools, infrastructure, etc. However, of that 30k, 10k goes into the pockets of executive bankers (golden parachutes, salaries, etc) or privately held companies. This does not really benefit me - I was expecting that money to go towards things that benefit me. That money will go back into the economy, but not to my (direct) benefit -- the bank execs will spend it on things that probably only benefit them. Only part of it will go back to taxes (whatever taxes the execs pay on their golden parachutes, salaries, etc). So, not only is my money being spent on things that do not benefit me, but it is rewarding the reckless behavior of bank executives. In shorter words: I am paying 30k to the government, I expect them to use that 30k to provide services that benefit everybody equally, not reward a few reckless bank execs.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoWhere did you get the idea that the government would be spending your $30k on public utilities? Most of your $30k would merely be taken and redistributed to other people. Another substantial chunk would be devoted to defending Europe from the Soviets/Islamists/whoever the military is actually set up to protect. http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/year2008_US.html http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/year2008_US.html I'm not sure why you feel more valuable to to take money from the banker and give it to old people than to allow the banker to invest in Netflix/Walmart/other businesses that provide value to millions of people. Could you explain?
- gavanwoolery 15y agoYes, I think you still miss the point though: Lets say 10k goes to this banker, and he spends it on Netflix/Wallmart/etc. That mostly benefits HIM. Really, I should get to spend that 10k on Wallmart/Netflix/etc. so that it benefits ME. Both cases benefit the economy, but the banker benefits more if he spends the money. In otherwords, money that I could spend on myself to boost the economy is instead being given to someone else who does not deserve it. Does that make sense? In general, I am for a SMALL government - that means I would prefer that taxes be minimized, and whatever can be privatized should be. I do not support our government's excessive defense budget (although I do support the troops, who actually get very little of the overall defense budget).
- muhfuhkuh 15y agoSo, you advocate tax revenue aggregating to the Fed, then the redistribution being managed by private banks? Shouldn't that up to the People? I guess there's just some political dissonance I perceive in the comments here: On one hand it's not okay if the government uses taxpayer revenue to "redistribute wealth" back to the people because, and I'm back-napkinning here, it'll fall into an endless void of unsustainable amounts of soulless feral children, big and flat screen TVs in every room including the bathroom, and shiny accoutrements for unaffordable cars. Oh, and let's ignore food and clothes because these savage poor and old people wear tatters to protect their shame and also eat their rims. But, miraculously, all those products and pharmaceuticals and adult undergarments and electric motor scooters for the mall are somehow not units of work exchanged for units of money. It's a pit -- a hungry, ceaseless, unending pit of despair that we should starve and force into servitude and submission rather than give a dime to. On the other hand, it's okay if banks who form the FOMC distributed tax revenue to themselves because it'll get reallocated to other rich people across the globe, who as we all know are accountable for 100% of the jobs and job growth that has or will ever be made in the history of US commerce, Amen. Oh, and (jedi hand wave) forget the crash of 2008, the S&L bailout of the 80s, the Great Depression, and all the various major crashes in between all fueled by speculation and 20x margin accounts and other toxic assets. They'll always do good by the taxpayer. Always.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoSo, you advocate tax revenue aggregating to the Fed, then the redistribution being managed by private banks? I didn't advocate any policy, I merely pointed out a logical error by the author.