2 ms·
The study was disgusting; I've commented about it in another thread. But I think there's something else here that explains the strong reactions people are havin
by noduerme 5y ago
The study was disgusting; I've commented about it in another thread. But I think there's something else here that explains the strong reactions people are having to this.
We as software engineers are not used to being told by a government how to build our code. If China passes some law saying that you can't directly search a database without routing the call through a government server, I don't care. I'm not going to research their laws and make sure my code conforms to that. It's not my problem. It's the people of China's problem. If a company I'm working for has a legal team that says they need to accommodate that, they'll tell me they need to write some code to do it. I'm free to write it for the money, or tell them to fuck the CCP and themselves.
But if I happen to know that a client is using my code in China without meeting some regulation there, it's not my obligation to inform them. Best of luck. I'm not personally liable for that.
And so what happened here is, they went after developers and small self-coded sites. They intentionally went after the people writing the code, not the companies that have legal compliance departments.
So the big question it presents, that I think has some people hopping mad and other people too sanguine, is: Does this herald a wave of assault and blackmail against developers, where bad actors (or dumb actors, like Princeton undergrads) will use supposed infractions of local laws to try to extort settlements from makers of software? I mean, show me a piece of software, and I'm sure it would be illegal somewhere. But the question of threatening small developers this way is new - it's a new form of trolling, like patent trolling but potentially even worse. The novelty of it and the potential for abuse is why I think a lot of people have been outraged by it, more than the question of whether someone should have just ignored this particular email. It presents an entirely new chilling effect that changes the bar for anyone looking to start a website, among other things. If any newbie coder had to make sure their code conformed to every legal requirement around the planet before putting it online, their chances of being successful with new code would be nil, and our livelihoods and creative capacities would be severely diminished. Our entire culture of making things would be crushed. An entire category of artistic creativity and originality that most of our lives are based upon could be shut down completely by a blizzard of emails like this one. I don't think it's overreacting to be alarmed by it, nor to be furious at this approach being pioneered by a supposedly liberal institution.