4 ms·
Would more funding have actually uncovered this?
by UncleMeat 5y ago
Would more funding have actually uncovered this?
- darkr 5y agoNot in and of itself.. However if part of that funding was used to cover formal (external) audits, investment in fuzzing/automated security testing etc.. then it might well have done
- layer8 5y agoThat’s a really big "if" though.
- svieira 5y ago"Might have" is the operative word. In a world where Project Zero's _This shouldn't have happened_ [1] was also published this month (buffer overflow on NSS), I'm less certain. Quoted from the article: ---- This wasn’t a process failure, the vendor did everything right. Mozilla has a mature, world-class security team. They pioneered bug bounties, invest in memory safety, fuzzing and test coverage. NSS was one of the very first projects included with oss-fuzz, it was officially supported since at least October 2014. Mozilla also fuzz NSS themselves with libFuzzer, and have contributed their own mutator collection and distilled coverage corpus. There is an extensive testsuite, and nightly ASAN builds. I'm generally skeptical of static analysis, but this seems like a simple missing bounds check that should be easy to find. Coverity has been monitoring NSS since at least December 2008, and also appears to have failed to discover this. Until 2015, Google Chrome used NSS, and maintained their own testsuite and fuzzing infrastructure independent of Mozilla. Today, Chrome platforms use BoringSSL, but the NSS port is still maintained. Did Mozilla have good test coverage for the vulnerable areas? YES. Did Mozilla/chrome/oss-fuzz have relevant inputs in their fuzz corpus? YES. Is there a mutator capable of extending ASN1_ITEMs? YES. Is this an intra-object overflow, or other form of corruption that ASAN would have difficulty detecting? NO, it's a textbook buffer overflow that ASAN can easily detect. ---- [1]: https://googleprojectzero.blogspot.com/2021/12/this-shouldnt-have-happened.html https://googleprojectzero.blogspot.com/2021/12/this-shouldnt...
- xyproto 5y agoNo. Funded projects also contains bugs.
- yawaramin 5y agoWould less funding have uncovered it?
- rileymat2 5y agoWould less funding have prevented the feature being implemented? Maybe?
- yawaramin 5y agoThere's no way to argue that less than zero funding would have prevented the log4j maintainers from merging a patch that was sent to them by a third party.
- anchpop 5y agoprobably not but i don’t think anyone suggested less funding
- yawaramin 5y agoWell I don't think anyone suggested anything actually helpful or relevant, so....