5 ms·
Civil asset forfeiture encourages criminality in police. This, along with qualified immunity, are significant drivers behind the 'defund' movement. Reforming
by klyrs 5y ago
Civil asset forfeiture encourages criminality in police. This, along with qualified immunity, are significant drivers behind the 'defund' movement. Reforming these two policies would be entirely sensible, if the country wasn't so hopelessly polarized.
- syshum 5y agofor most political reforms it seems the news media purposely chooses the most polarizing examples of the problem to highlight. Does not matter if police reform, abortion, welfare, or any other topic, the media chooses the examples that will most upset those opposing the reform. This results in nothing getting reform, maintaining the status quo, and the media;s reoccurring revenue stream The nation is hopelessly polarized as a direct result of media propaganda, I have encountered this everyday and when people are giving actual non-sensationalized facts it is very easy to come to compromise policy position.
- salimmadjd 5y agoThe same polarizing media conveniently blamed Facebook and Twitter (though to a lesser extent) for all the polarization that they have been fomenting for years. I guess that move wasn’t as surprising for me as seeing the number of people in SV who bought into that narrative. Corporate media should not really be thought of as real journalistic entities. Simple example. How in the world does CNN allow Chris Cuomo to interview his own brother. The fact that no one inside CNN publicly objected to this, walked away, protested, it tells me everything I need to know about the entire organization. I don’t remember anyone at MSNBC making a fuss about it, nor at the Washington Post (Democracy Dies in Darkness).
- kurthr 5y agoHmmm, yeah no. Whether it's Vanity Fair or other "liberal scions", they're as likely to point out the issues with this sort of self-serving coverage as your favorite hand wringer on Fox News, who themselves are almost entirely "entertainment" and have so much obvious conflict of interest in their coverage... and if the Jan 6 SMS messages are to be believed, simple out right lying. https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/03/02/chris-cuomo-andrew-cuomo-cnn-disclosure/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/03/02/chris-cuo...
- zimpenfish 5y ago> How in the world does CNN allow Chris Cuomo to interview his own brother. To be fair to CNN, they did ban that from 2013 until it was temporarily lifted in 2020 because "Chris speaking with his brother about the challenges of what millions of American families were struggling with was of significant human interest"[1]. It was definitely a bad judgement call but hardly damning of the whole organisation. [1] https://eu.usatoday.com/story/entertainment/tv/2021/02/19/cnns-chris-cuomo-can-no-longer-interview-brother-gov-andrew-cuomo/4504315001/ https://eu.usatoday.com/story/entertainment/tv/2021/02/19/cn...
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoI've stuck to here, New Yorker, NYT, and The Atlantic, I've stayed off of social media, I don't have cable and I don't watch TV. This site's articles and comments are often the most polarizing media that I subject myself to daily. I think most polarization comes from media packaged with a comment section and low quality news outlets.
- syshum 5y agoIf the only news media on consume is New Yorker, NYT and The Atlantic (all of which are rated as Left Bias news sources) then you are likely already in an echo chamber, so when exposed to a non-echo chamber source with comments (like HN) you come way with a false attribution as to what is propaganda, and what the source of that propaganda is
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoI think you're in the "New Yorker, NYT, and The Atlantic are echo chambers" echo chamber. I don't believe or agree with everything that I read. I also read a fair amount of different opinions in these sources which leads me to believe it's more varied than you would like to believe. It's interesting because I've always considered myself center/center right politically.
- syshum 5y agoMy position on those organizations political bias is from ratings by several independent organizations such as Ground News (but not only them) which I have been using more recently. I read 100's of news sources weekly, and if topic I want information on I drill down beyond the news organization seeking out orginal sources (for example if a news organization is reporting on a COVID Study, I read the study. If they are reporting on the 6th circuits ruling, I go read the ruling.. etc) It is ironic that someone the proudly proclaims they only consume information from 3 sources proclaims I am in an echo chamber but they could never be... lol As for my political leanings, I more of a Political Compass person where by economics is Left/Right, under which I am almost exactly in the enter, but social is on a Authority / Liberty scale, of which I am on the extreme end of the liberty scale
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoI agree with you. I don't like that being pro police became a cult of letting them do whatever they want. I'm pro police and I believe they should be paid more, get more training, and be held to much higher standard which means relentlessly pursuing and strongly prosecuting corrupt police. It's a betrayal of an entire community in a profession where lives are often at stake. Being pro police also doesn't mean making their job as easy as possible to the detriment of everybody else.
- syshum 5y agoWell IMO one of the problem here is thinking in either "pro" or "anti" group stances. I am neither pro police, nor anti police. I am pro enforcement of laws that protect people from being victimized by others. That is a very narrow statement that does not require me to be "pro police" or "anti police" >> I believe they should be paid more, get more training, and be held to much higher standard This is often a position people take, but if fails root cause analysis. I am not convinced that more training, more pay, and higher standards will fix anything. The root cause is 2 fold first over-criminalization of society, and the use of police to enforce things that should not be crimes in the first place, or should be left to civil enforcement. The second is then giving police more power than average citizen, and I am not just talking arresting power there is a solid case there. However governments pass all kinds of laws written that have specific carve outs for police, this creates a "higher class" member of society that allows the member of this class to believe they are the sovereign and we are the vessels this fly's in the face of governance "For the people, by the people" aka self governance. IMO the law itself creates the logical end result of the policing we have today, unless we change the law the police no matter the pay, training, or standards will still be a problem
- shakezula 5y ago> this creates a "higher class" member of society This is a really good way of describing what people are really angry about. Cop worship in the states is only second to God.
- tehwebguy 5y agoGood reminder to vote your district attorney or equivalent out of office every single election unless they are relentless about prosecuting police who break the law. Weird examples that never go away, you can see instances of these every single day: - Tons of LAPD drive with illegal tints & no tags on their personal vehicles - Tons of NYPD park in the bike lane or on the actual sidewalk There are twitter accounts that follow these easy to spot examples. Harder to track: abuses of power in small towns when no cameras are rolling. DAs have even more leeway in some states than others, for instance in New York felonies can only be charged via grand jury unless waived by the defendant. This gives a DA unilateral power to sandbag any indictment they don’t feel like prosecuting without looking soft on bad cops (see the Buffalo shoving incident) with zero transparency.
- authed 5y ago> Reforming these two policies would be entirely sensible, if the country wasn't so hopelessly polarized. I guess it will have to get a lot worst before it gets better...
- CoastalCoder 5y ago> Civil asset forfeiture encourages criminality in police. If you'll forgive a moment of polemic: In my judgment, civil-asset forfeiture is a crime, full-stop. As a regular citizen without special legal training, it seems like as blatant a violation of the 5th Amendment as one could imagine. Perhaps with more legal training I'd judge it differently. But I'm not ready to give the court system the benefit of the doubt on this. And I would be deeply skeptical of any argument to the contrary. If the SCOTUS can justify civil-asset forfeiture (in its current form), then I don't see how the Bill of Rights offers any protection at all.
- nescioquid 5y ago> As a regular citizen without special legal training... Living in a free society or not, you are fit to judge the rectitude of the law. To suggest otherwise implies a servile relationship of the citizen to the state. All manner of abominable laws have existed and been upheld under all forms of the US constitution. Qualified advocates argued against, and supreme court judges ruled against Dred Scott (7 - 2), for instance. As long as it has existed, the supreme court has been in a crisis of legitimacy, and upholding the appearance of legitimacy has been its prima causa. What separates you and a fine judgement of what is just? Three years of sophistical "scholarship" and two summers of internships?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hellojesus 5y agoIt is a violation of the constitution full stop. Also, TSA gets kickbacks from homeland security. If they see large sums of cash in your bags, they will contact the police in order to try and get it taken via civil asset forfeiture, and then they'll get a kickback for it. I plan to start traveling with wads of prop money with a couple hundreds on the outside to get a lel out of the interaction when the cops inevitably show up to try and confiscate it.
- landemva 5y agoQualified immunity was created by USSC. It is widely abused by all levels of government, and can be fixed by legislature.
- indymike 5y agoI'm not sure there is any objection to reforming this on either side. Civil forfeiture seems blatantly plain-language unconstitutional.
- klyrs 5y agoIf only the legislature could sit down and write single-issue bills with clear bipartisan support... but I'm not sure you're right. The phrase "law and order" seems to shut down rational thought, and there are plenty of politicians on both sides of the aisle who appear to act at the whim of police lobbies. When confronted with the blatant unconstitutionality of the patriot act, Democrats and Republicans alike responded "yeah, but police are using it to fight crime."
- indymike 5y ago> The phrase "law and order" seems to shut down rational thought Insecurity shuts down rational thought. Lew and order only works where insecurity exists. > plenty of politicians on both sides of the aisle who appear to act at the whim of police lobbies. Insecurity gets you unelected.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoLibertarians have been talking about it for decades, but it seems lately that even some public outlets have been talking about it. I don't know if it's getting worse or finally coming to public notice.