3 ms·
I'm not defending Yelp. I'm just saying there's no evidence that Yelp is widely hated amongst average people. (I assume it's not, but I don't have any data fo
by jrockway 15y ago
I'm not defending Yelp. I'm just saying there's no evidence that Yelp is widely hated amongst average people. (I assume it's not, but I don't have any data for that either.)
I can't explain their filtering algorithm because I didn't write their filtering algorithm. Ultimately, automatic fraud assessment is the only way Yelp is going to scale; it's too expensive to have a human validate every review, so you get the computer to do it for you. 99% of the time, it works. 1% of the time, you get the situation where the dog training company gets screwed. It's like when your credit card gets flagged for buying gas out of state or using an ATM in China. It's annoying that you got false-positived for fraud, but that's what happens. It's the only way the credit-card system can work. Same for Yelp's filtering; no automatic filtering, no Yelp.
The problem with Yelp is that people don't take it with a grain of salt. But that's not Yelp's problem, that's a "people are morons" problem.
- salemh 15y agoI wonder the psychology (of many review sites) that people are more motivation to seek out area's to post negative reviews, rather then a positive. Lack of a business "if you enjoyed our service please let us know via (Yelp, Google Pages, etc.) which may net a higher return of happy customers. I personally more inclined to hop on Yelp as a warning to other consumers on a poor business, vs, just random "ups" to other well run businesses. I gain no benefit but altruistic feelings, and this, takes time. The time it takes to post a negative review is rewarding in itself to try and "help" others avoid or be wary of said business. Also, markets should take a factor in analysis of Yelp reviews. As an example, larger cities have a much higher preponderance of reviews as a whole, where even medium (what I would call them) such as SLC (where I live) are very sparse and therefore limited in search / decision making.