4 ms·
>2) This product does not come with appropriate warnings[0] that this is a possibility, while, according to comments here, hazards of the battery used are commo
by gruez 5y ago
>2) This product does not come with appropriate warnings[0] that this is a possibility, while, according to comments here, hazards of the battery used are common knowledge among engineers
should it? especially when the risk is so low and warnings like "contents may be hot" on coffee cups or " This product contains chemicals known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm" are widely derided?
- romwell 5y ago>should it? Yes, it should, because people expect wireless headphones to be as safe as wired ones, which have exactly 0% (zero, zlich, nada) chance of spontaneously catching on fire. Wired headphones are still widely used, made, and sold. This would allow the consumers to make an informed choice, and will give the manufactures of safe devices (wired or wireless) the deserved edge in the market. Also, consider the comments just from this thread about the risks: >In the end you're carrying a high energy density power source on your head that would love to just catch fire. Don't they teach kids anything in chemistry these days? >I mean I’m glad it didn’t happen to me, but a billion people are carrying around billions of Lithium-ion batteries. Those batteries sometimes catch fire because Lithium is highly flammable. It’s gonna happen. >Nothing is perfectly safe, that is how lithium batteries fail. You should know so you can properly deal with problems. >Well, at lease EVs are spontaneously catching fire. >Everyone is aware of the risks, there were a bunch of stories about airplane cell phone fires a few years ago. >lithium battery fires are really nasty, and that's why he got a chemical burn. LiPF6 is a contact irritant, PF5 it decomposes to is a gas, and also a respiratory irritant, and HF PH5 decomposes in the air is a dangerous poisonous acid. This is what everybody visiting a lithium battery factory is told on safety orientation. In case there is fire in the factory, run, preferably until you are few blocks away. So, paradoxically, the risks are both negligible and inevitable, something that every consumer should be prepared for because "everyone knows" batteries explode, but no manufacturer should warn about, mitigate, or account for in the design because who'd buy their product then? I hope you agree that the above is self-contradictory. Now, ultimately, warnings are not a panacea, but they do work. At the very least, having their product labeled as "unsafe to use in bed" would make the manufacturers invest in research that would result in a better product that doesn't merit such a label.
- jdavis703 5y ago> So, paradoxically, the risks are both negligible and inevitable, something that every consumer should be prepared for because "everyone knows" batteries explode, but no manufacturer should warn about, mitigate, or account for in the design because who'd buy their product then? I think this can all be true. ER doctors say avocados are one of the most dangerous fruits because of knife accidents. Yet avocados don’t come with any warnings or mitigations. And for the general public, you probably don’t know any one who was severely injured slicing an avocado. Surely avocado farmers should be working on cultivars that have a small or no pit so people don’t get injured preparing these fruits? (I mean that only half sarcastically, I would enjoy a seedless avocado if it tasted the same.)
- throwaway984393 5y agoI wouldn't mind a sign over the avocado bin at the supermarket warning consumers about knife injuries and an infographic showing the correct way to cut them. The avocado lobby has enough money to help fund it. I kind of like the giant seeds. It reminds me that this bizarre fruit is a leftover from megafauna eating and pooping out the giant seeds over long distances (you need a big seed to survive dinosaur digestion)
- jdavis703 5y agoMaybe, is there any evidence Prop 65 warnings have reduced people buying carcinogenic foods in California supermarkets?
- romwell 5y agoYou seem to ask the question in bad faith, as clearly this is not the right place to find out these statistics. Google is your friend. There is evidence that warnings, in general, do work. There is also evidence that wired headphones, which don't have batteries in them, do not self-combust and therefore will not require such a label. A label that differentiates products is certainly useful. There is also plenty of evidence that most people are unaware of the potential dangers of lithium batteries. There is no parallel with Prop 65 warnings here.
- neilparikh 5y ago> " This product contains chemicals known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm" are widely derided? The problem with those warnings is not their existence, but the fact they are unspecific. If the ingredients on food containers just said "This contains an allergen", people would ignore them too. The way to make the California warnings useful would be to list which specific chemical is the problem, so that it is actionable. Similarly, for the headphones case, listing the specific problem allows the user to take into account their specific situation (climate, usage pattern etc.) to decide if it's applicable to them. Obviously if the warning just said "this is hazardous", it's worse than useless.