3 ms·
One of the early patch sets had a much higher speed of light; but it was eventually fixed. There's debate about further revising it in a future release; but no
by h2odragon 5y ago
One of the early patch sets had a much higher speed of light; but it was eventually fixed.
There's debate about further revising it in a future release; but no consensus on if it needs to be faster or slower. People kept hard coding it as a constant so the legacy issues would make the tachyon situation look simple.
More seriously: when the Universe was smaller and denser could the speed of light been higher, analogous to speed of sound in higher pressure and density materials?
- jfengel 5y agoDensity doesn't figure into it. It's about space itself, rather than the rate at which light travels. Light in a vacuum moves at that rate, which is a straightforward constant that figures into several other things. The space itself does change and you could try to redefine the formulas in terms of a changing speed of light, but it just makes it harder. The space metric fits very neatly into the Einstein field equations, and the expanding universe pops out of that directly. The acceleration doesn't, but it's a very simple tweak to make it do so. (Einstein had originally added that tweak to make the universe not expand, but then expansion was discovered.) If you change the speed of light you throw off chemistry, and all of the observations of distant galaxies show that chemistry still works. So a changing speed of light is unlikely.
- uh_uh 5y ago> The space metric fits very neatly into the Einstein field equations, and the expanding universe pops out of that directly. Is there a simple way to understand why? I don't have an understanding of the relevant math. It's a bit hard for me to imagine how we get from the axiom of "speed of light is constant in every reference frame" to an expanding universe. Unless there are other axioms used for this.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agothe other axiom you need is that gravity and acceleration are the same. the speed of light being constant only gets you special relativity.
- raattgift 5y agoThe equivalence is between uniform acceleration and a uniform gravitational field. Breaking the uniformity, which the universe does for us whether we like it or not, has consequences. Real gravitational sources aren't uniform (they tend towards spherical) and come equipped with a tidal field with a potential and gradient. This is intrinsically gravitational, not accelerational. The non-uniform distribution of matter (including radiation) in the universe also matters. You can rest an accelerometer on the surface of the Earth and it will report ~ 1 g (upwards) for many -- even billions of -- years, with no ill effect. How long can you accelerate a rocket containing an identical accelerometer? Consider fuel, and crashing into matter (up to distant starlight and the cosmic microwave radiation) after a few months (of ship time) of the accelerometer indicating ~ 1 g (forwards). You don't get strong twin-paradox effects involving the Moon-walking astronauts, or long-mission robot probes on the Moon or Mars, even though the local equivalent of "g" is considerably lower than that here on Earth. By comparison, if you and and two roughly identical astronauts were to undergo hundreds of days (or Martian sols, or a few lunar days) ship's time in spacecraft doing a round-trip under constant accelerations of ~ 1g, 0.6g, and 0.17g respectively, the lesser-accelerated "twins" would be visibly older than you at the end of your respective round-trip journeys.
- jfengel 5y agoIt comes out of extending that to an accelerating reference frame, which gives you a curved spacetime. That doesn't stay stable by itself. It has to either expand or contract, depending on how much energy is in it. (Mass is a form of energy, and so you get gravity.) It's a bit like noticing that objects can't float. They can either fly away or fall but they can't just sit there. It's not exactly the same thing, since we're talking about the spacetime itself rather than gravity as separate from the objects, but the analogy mostly works.
- contravariant 5y agoThe speed of light is just a constant for converting units of time into distances, even if the speed of light were to change we'd probably choose to just change the units of distance to forcibly keep it constant.
- wavefunction 5y agoThe speed of light differs depending on the medium it's transiting already though. I've wondered in the past if in the primordial universe time or space were different than what we've observed "now." It seems like they could both compress or expand like other physical characteristics of reality.
- contravariant 5y agoThere's two different meanings for the phrase 'the speed of light'. One is the conversion constant I mentioned (which is currently used to define the metre in terms of time and is therefore constant by definition). The other is the speed at which light travels (through a medium).
- sp332 5y agoIt's still an exotic model, but if there's an extra dimension that light can fit into - even a tiny loop that it just spirals around as it propagates - then it's possible that at higher energy densities, it spirals at a shallower angle. That would make it appear to propagate through the three normal spatial dimensions faster even if it has the same speed across all four dimensions. João Magueijo wrote an approachable book on this called "Faster than the Speed of Light: The Story of a Scientific Speculation".