4 ms·
My 2c. I think part of what makes humanity transcend much of the rest of the animal kingdom is the ability to build on the past through the generations. We do
by travisgriggs 5y ago
My 2c.
I think part of what makes humanity transcend much of the rest of the animal kingdom is the ability to build on the past through the generations. We do it through oral/written tradition/history, etc. I think these “silly” mythological rituals help bind generations. Generational angst has always been a thing, but I worry that it’s grown worse of late than in the past. But I have no way of quantifiably proving that.
I view this idea (generational evolution being the hook that powers our progress) as a basic abstraction of the final verse found at the end of the Old Testament
“He will turn the hearts of the parents to their children, and the hearts of the children to their parents; or else I will come and strike the land with total destruction.”
You can take the rest of the OT myth|doctrine and throw it out or love it; I think this idea stands on its own.
The HN community often discusses the future, and we bemoan the lack of forethought for future generations. I think this is important. But I also think sometimes we don’t connect with the past in ways we should. We should learn from our history. We should honor the good those in the past have accomplished. We should cut them some slack, avoid over projecting, and do our best to make the next generational version better.
To me, these silly traditions play a part in strengthening those ties in both directions. They may seem irrational in many ways, but the universe has more irrational numbers than rational ones, so I’m ok catering to a little bit of balanced irrationality.
- hattmall 5y agoProsecuting the past is one of the most useless expenditures of energy possible. Instead of pursuing some beneficial or productive avenue we have people today who are organizing and protesting over the actions of people who are literally dead. I think this has to be a unique point in the history of humans where as instead of trying to make some change geared towards bettering things for future generations we have energy being expensed towards just being mad about the past.
- vlovich123 5y agoWhen people are just following the rituals then it’s not a protest over actions that happened in the past by people since dead. It’s a protest of the continuing harm being felt by those groups. It’s also a recognition that those problematic self sustaining rituals are sometimes hard to see from the inside.
- agumonkey 5y agoAdd to that the fact that societies evolve way faster than before. In the past you'd inherit your ancestors knowledge and carry it forward because it would still matter. It binds parents with infants through transmission of memories, skills. Now very few of my life means anything in the age of Meta. And my kids will be too busy creating ebusiness on discord with his followers.