5 ms·
I'm the person who wrote that blog post. I got an email from a fake person in France who asked several questions about my small social media site's CCPA complia
by kstrauser 5y ago
I'm the person who wrote that blog post. I got an email from a fake person in France who asked several questions about my small social media site's CCPA compliance, then ended the letter with:
> I look forward to your reply without undue delay and at most within 45 days of this email, as required by Section 1798.130 of the California Civil Code.
I thought I was about to be sued by someone who was the equivalent of a patent troll, but for the CCPA. I had a minor panic attack before I was able to calm down and piece together an open response (as I wasn't about to reply directly to them, not after their thinly veiled legal threat). I briefly considered lawyering up just in case, which would have cost me a fair chunk of money.
After all that, it turns out it was research by Princeton University: https://privacystudy.cs.princeton.edu https://privacystudy.cs.princeton.edu
The lead researcher, Ross Teixeira, says that:
> We submitted an application detailing our research methods to the Princeton University Institutional Review Board, which determined that our study does not constitute human subjects research. The focus of the study is understanding website policies and practices, and emails associated with the study do not solicit personally identifiable information.
Either:
1. Teixeira misrepresented his research to the IRB, or
2. The IRB is grossly incompetent or unimaginative.
I don't see a middle ground on this, particularly after the University of Minnesota vs Linux contributors debacle (see https://www.theverge.com/2021/4/30/22410164/linux-kernel-university-of-minnesota-banned-open-source https://www.theverge.com/2021/4/30/22410164/linux-kernel-uni...). I see Teixeira's research as the equivalent of sending a bunch of fake legal notices to random people to "study the legal system", while claiming with a straight face that it doesn't involve human subjects research. Frankly, that's bullshit, and I can't believe someone signed off on this.
As noted on the blog post, I've reported this to Princeton's Research Integrity & Assurance department. This isn't OK. I didn't consent to be a part of their human research (which it absolutely is, however they might try to claim otherwise), and this research seriously freaked me out. I slept poorly for a couple of days thinking I was facing possible legal issues over hosting a little not-for-profit hobby website.
- Paul-E 5y agoI've met Ross during my time at Princeton and he is a really genuine person, he is not trying to ruin anyone's life. This incident is the result of an uncharacteristic blind spot in empathy: a mistake. I also have experience with the Princeton IRB on similar topics. The reality is that Princeton's IRB, and IRBs in general, are not equipped to deal with this sort of online research. IRBs were created as a reaction to unethical medical research, in particular the Tuskegee Syphilis Study [1]. My experience has been that the IRB has a greater expertise on medical and sociological studies. This leads the IRB to having a very narrow view of its remit in other domains. Unless humans are in a very literal way "subjects" of the study, then the IRB doesn't see it as human subjects research. In this case the IRB likely saw "Free Radical" and other websites as the subject. In both my studies and those done by my peers, the responses on what is and isn't human subjects research is uneven and you will often get a generic "this study does not constitute human subjects research" response from the IRB. This can be the case even if there possible negative repercussions to the "not subjects" in your research. For example, say your study involves testing the vulnerability disclosure policies. How well do websites respond to vuln reports? In your study you send out 100 vulnerability disclosures. After you report these vulnerabilities, a human may read your vulnerability report and make a decision based on it. This presents a risk that the individual security team employees involved in your study will be scapegoated and fired when you publish your (potentially damning) results. How do you balance the value this study provides the public against the risk to the individual employees' livelihoods? The IRB isn't going to help you do this balancing, they will just say "this isn't human subjects research". IRBs quite simply aren't equipped to evaluate this sort of research at the moment. This can be frustrating for a young twenty-something researcher just out of college trying to do the right thing while generating impactful research. You come in thinking that the IRB will be a guiding hand of wisdom and prudence, but you are quickly disabused of that notion after most of your interactions feel like conversations with lawyers in a compliance department. Many researchers in "CS" don't even involve the IRB, because they don't always see the ethical dimension of their work, but the fact that Ross did shows that he was trying to do the right thing here. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuskegee_Syphilis_Study https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuskegee_Syphilis_Study
- vessenes 5y agoQuick meta-comment; this is useful and informative information about the original link - please don’t downvote because you disagree with the point of view. If you disagree, please add a comment and make HN a great place for discourse!
- wglb 5y agoDownvotes are ok to use to indicate and it has been so forever. Pg and others have supported this view
- kstrauser 5y agoI don’t doubt that Ross is a nice person, and I think he meant well. FWIW, I think this is a great thing to study and in other circumstances I’d be glad he’s doing it. But much as Ross didn’t intend for me to be hyperventilating, heart pounding as I imagine trying to explain to my wife how my little hobby is getting us sued, that’s exactly what happened. That was a whole awful lot of extra stress that I didn’t need.
- geofft 5y agoThe fact that Ross didn't mean to do this is all the more reason why someone - maybe an IRB, maybe not (your argument makes sense) - should be assisting 20-something researchers with having a well-informed perspective. In the absence of an organization that's good at this (which doesn't seem to exist and should), this probably should be the supervising professors.
- michaelhoffman 5y agoAs a research group leader, I find it unfortunate that the grad student seems to be the public face of this and is therefore attracting most of the ire. Feels like the student is being thrown under the bus, and responsibility for ensuring the study is conducted ethically should ultimately be that of the principal investigator.
- 5y ago
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y agoYou did not lawyer up, but some other recipient might have had. Is there a ground for a lawsuit here for... well.. fraud? After all, resources were spent; surely, there was some stress.. Yeah, I agree with you.
- kstrauser 5y agoI'm not a lawyer, clearly, but I'd say so. Some people are replying to him on Twitter saying that they've spent money here and asking who to send the invoice to.
- Ekaros 5y agoNot a lawyer, but I would say no. Being aware of your legal obligations is part of cost of doing business. Expecting company to follow law isn't anything special. Just because in past they have been unethical and not spend money to follow them doesn't mean when they hear about it and spend money the person they heard about it from has to pay. That would be insane. They have been bad people by not following the laws or being aware. Now they are aware of them. In no way is him responsible for these idiots legal cost. Specially when they should have already paid them before.
- simple_phrases 5y agoHere's to hoping you're awarded damages for pain and suffering, or at least get a nice settlement.
- kstrauser 5y agoIf there's a settlement, I hope it's in the form of a nice bottle of scotch, and a letter from Princeton apologizing and swearing not to do it again. I'm not out money; I'm out peace of mind.
- simple_phrases 5y agoI just hope there is some incentive for other researchers to not follow in this study's footsteps.
- annoyingnoob 5y agoI don't think this reaches the level of a cash settlement, personally. It is certainly shocking and would upset me. I agree that Princeton should try harder.
- kstrauser 5y agoSame. I’m neither asking for nor wanting any kind of a settlement or anything. I just want them not to do it again.
- nickff 5y agoI agree that you were wronged by these so-called ‘researchers’, but it’s also tragic that our legal systems are so bad that everyone fears them. The legal system should be a low-stress, reliable, and predictable way to avoid or reduce conflict, instead of a weapon of terror.
- kstrauser 5y agoThat's a fair point. The text of the CCPA is very clear that it doesn't apply to my hobby website (see https://oag.ca.gov/privacy/ccpa https://oag.ca.gov/privacy/ccpa for a nice FAQ), but I wasn't thrilled about the idea of having to explain that to a jury.
- tsumnia 5y agoWhat's more annoying is that the decision to construct the email as a non-academic "other person" was a CONSCIOUS decision by the research team (most likely the advisor). I don't see what benefit hiding behind the illusion gathered does for the information beyond worrying the recipients wouldn't respond to a more traditional "We are researching CCPA..." style email. IRB does allow for deception, just to be clear. Its annoying, but sometimes that's what's needed to get genuine responses. HOWEVER, the hoops the team needed to do to justify its use here was very poorly executed.
- pseudalopex 5y agoImplying the law said they had to respond looks like a bigger problem to me. Some people said they wouldn't have ignored email from a researcher. So saying it was for research would have changed the responses.
- labcomputer 5y agoMight be worth reaching out to Princeton's IRB? https://undergraduateresearch.princeton.edu/compliance/human-research https://undergraduateresearch.princeton.edu/compliance/human...
- kstrauser 5y agoDone, thanks. I'm not sure what the difference is between that and their RIA (https://ria.princeton.edu/report-concern https://ria.princeton.edu/report-concern), but now I've reported it to both.
- ineedasername 5y agoThe IRB is underneath the RIA. If this was the IRB's screwup, it's the RIA they will answer to. And probably a nice chat with general counsel to assess any liability.
- dangom 5y agoYou should report this to the IRB. The research is conducted on information obtained by interacting with humans, and therefore should be classify as Human Subjects Research [1]. Waivers of informed consent can be obtained under some circumstances, for example in the case of a retrospective study where the data has already been collected and contacting subjects would be difficult/unnecessary, or it can be shown to adversely affect the outcomes of the study [2, search for waiver]. But regardless, even if informed consent were to be waived, the fact that this is human research means that the researchers should be trained in Research Ethics and Good Clinical Practice (even if the research is not clinical), and understand that the goal is always to minimize risk for the participants - risk which was clearly not properly evaluated under the current project. [1] https://grants.nih.gov/policy/humansubjects/research.htm https://grants.nih.gov/policy/humansubjects/research.htm [2] https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/45/46.116 https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/45/46.116
- kstrauser 5y agoThat’s great information, thanks! I’m learning an awful lot about this stuff very quickly.
- ajkjk 5y agoI don't understand why you reacted so strongly. I feel like it's not a big deal to receive a message like that; what am I missing?
- annoyingnoob 5y agoHave you ever been a sole proprietor in California[0]? Do you have a family? Adding something about a timeframe and quoting the law clearly signals legal troubles. I would have 'reacted strongly' too. [0] https://www.ftb.ca.gov/file/business/types/sole-proprietorship.html https://www.ftb.ca.gov/file/business/types/sole-proprietorsh...
- nkrisc 5y agoBecause it sounds like a letter you’d receive from someone who’s prepared to abuse the legal system to extract money from you. Also I think the OP pretty well described their reaction: they were afraid they were going to be sued.
- kstrauser 5y agoI'm just running a hobby website. I'm not at all used to receiving letters that bring up legal questions, then give me a time frame to reply as per a specific law. To my non-lawyer reading, that looks like someone's doing their homework to figure out how to drag me into court. Judging from a lot of the responses I've gotten from other recipients, I'm far from the only one.
- N00bN00b 5y agoI don't know buddy... Might be worth it to invest some time into anxiety/stress management. Meditation, keep an eye on your sleep, exercise, maybe go talk to someone. You're not supposed to have anxiety attacks over fairly lame sounding emails. Not to mention, it's just a matter of time before you get another (spam/scam) email like this. I get these quite frequently? I don't know how often, but definitely at least one a month. Either it's about my taxes not filed or my student debt, or some loan I didn't pay. Not worth having anxiety attacks over, minor or otherwise.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ineedasername 5y agoThere is a separate Research Integrity group to address exactly this sort of problem. I'd call and email them [0] and then maybe cc' the office of General Council (their lawyers) [1] so they are aware of the type of liability that lax research oversight may be causing. For good measure, his research advisors should hear about this as well. Per his own website (now unavailable but archived on wayback [2]) they are Jonathan Mayer [3] and Jenifer Rexford. [4] Ross: should you come across this HN post, read through every comment. You need to understand-- especially studying tech policy!!!-- just how poorly done this was. Really not a great way to begin your reputation in this field. [0] https://ria.princeton.edu/report-concern https://ria.princeton.edu/report-concern [1] https://ogc.princeton.edu/ https://ogc.princeton.edu/ [2] https://web.archive.org/web/20210122100955/https://www.rossteixeira.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20210122100955/https://www.rosst... [3] https://jonathanmayer.org/ https://jonathanmayer.org/ [4] https://www.cs.princeton.edu/~jrex/ https://www.cs.princeton.edu/~jrex/
- ineedasername 5y ago1. Teixeira misrepresented his research to the IRB, or 2. The IRB is grossly incompetent or unimaginative My experience with IRB's is that they are often extremely conservative in their interpretations. Legal liability is attached to them. Human-involved research requires an order of magnitude more review to get approved. There are gray areas, and my (very limited) direct observations are that people will try to frame their material to avoid the extra review. I can't rely completely on Princeton's reputation for this, but if I had to guess, Ross either did a poor job presenting to the IRB or deliberately downplayed the nature of the of things.
- jeroenhd 5y agoPoignant detail: the Radboud professor that's part of this "research" has experience in dark patterns so he knows damn well what he's doing. By his own words, from his website: > I also study anonymous communication networks such as Tor, and investigate deceptive and manipulative (dark) design patterns Radboud has policies about informed consent [1] that were clearly ignored, or were explained away with the idea that informing should be allowed afterwards to not taint the experiment (even though this is just a basic data policy). I believe the recipients of these emails should file a complaint against Teixeira's co-conspirator as well. Contact information for the Radboud ethic's board can be found at [2], though the documentation is mostly aimed at students. [1]: https://www.ru.nl/rdm/collecting-data/informed-consent-ethics-committees/ https://www.ru.nl/rdm/collecting-data/informed-consent-ethic... [2]: https://www.ru.nl/science/research/about-our-research/ethics-committee/ https://www.ru.nl/science/research/about-our-research/ethics...
- kstrauser 5y agoGreat advice, thanks! I’ve filed a complaint with Radboud, too.
- zippergz 5y agoI love how they say they are "contacting websites" as if websites are sentient beings that can respond to questions, rather than operations run by human beings who will receive and respond to the communication.
- kiklion 5y agoWebsites aren’t sentient beings, but they are more similar to commercial entities than people. Even if not intentional, websites gain traffic and can display ads. They have Google ranking. They have an audience and can get paid to share information with their audience. Would there be an issue if they sent out letters to businesses asking how they comply with a California regulation?
- ziddoap 5y ago>Would there be an issue if they sent out letters to businesses asking how they comply with a California regulation? I think this is where you may be overlooking the context. People aren't mad they asked about compliance with a law, they are mad about the way it was asked: from fake personas implying legal threat, while cataloguing the replies for their study no one asked to be involved in.
- pessimizer 5y agoThat seems like a pretense. The researcher was an actual human being, so all they would have to do to require a response is to register on the site before sending the email. If they had registered accounts, then requested their information be sent to them and required its deletion, it would have been an order of magnitude more work for the site owners than just sending answers about the process (which, if the site is subject to the law, should already be prepared.) I think people are mad precisely because they were asked about compliance with a law. Largely because emails went out to sites that were not commercial or too small to be bound by the law, so they weren't aware of it and panicked.
- toast0 5y ago
- kingcharles 5y agoI don't know California statutes, but in Illinois that would be a crime: (720 ILCS 5/17-50) (was 720 ILCS 5/16D-5 and 5/16D-6) Sec. 17-50. Computer fraud. (a) A person commits computer fraud when he or she knowingly: (1) Accesses or causes to be accessed a computer or any part thereof, or a program or data, with the intent of devising or executing any scheme or artifice to defraud, or as part of a deception;