6 ms·
> I feel like taking that away will severely disadvantage poor kids who are otherwise bright with strong work ethics. They can still take the test and get a hi
by jedberg 5y ago
> I feel like taking that away will severely disadvantage poor kids who are otherwise bright with strong work ethics.
They can still take the test and get a high score.
> How are the SAT/ACT not objective tests? Are they not objective measures of how you perform on the SAT/ACT?
Most of the studies on this show that all of the cultural references in the reading passages and math word problems were things that wealthy people would have experienced in real life, but poor people would not, so it gave an advantage to wealthy kids. Also a lot of the vocab were words that wealthy kids had heard at home but not poor kids.
So while it was supposed to be a test of intelligence, it is really a test of how wealthy you were growing up.
Edit:
Here is the main study from 2003 from Harvard: https://meridian.allenpress.com/her/article-abstract/73/1/1/31807/Correcting-the-SAT-s-Ethnic-and-Social-Class-Bias https://meridian.allenpress.com/her/article-abstract/73/1/1/...
Here is a writeup of someone who replicated it with more recent test scores: https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2010/06/21/new-evidence-racial-bias-sat https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2010/06/21/new-evidence-...
- hcurtiss 5y agoNo, it's a measure of how well you perform on the subjects tested by the SAT. There are many things that correlate with high SAT scores (e.g., grades, being Asian?), but it is definitely true that you can prep for the SAT without any meaningful amount of money. I don't believe that anybody has ever alleged that SAT scores are a proxy for intelligence, though I suspect there is a decent correlation. In my mind it is a useful, objective, universal measure of how an individual student is able to prepare for and execute on a difficult task.
- rayiner 5y agoSAT's are closely correlated with IQ tests: https://slate.com/technology/2014/04/what-do-sat-and-iq-tests-measure-general-intelligence-predicts-school-and-life-success.html https://slate.com/technology/2014/04/what-do-sat-and-iq-test...
- jedberg 5y ago> I don't believe that anybody has ever alleged that SAT scores are a proxy for intelligence MENSA accepts it for admission to their high IQ club.
- xapata 5y ago> meaningful amount of money Depends on how much money is meaningful to you. Time has its own costs, especially since an older teenager can work as an alternative.
- civilized 5y agoWith all due respect, the vast majority of us here took these tests. Do any of us remember them containing quizzes on obscure aspects of water polo and equestrianism and sailing jargon, or other things that only rich kids would know about? I remember them being fairly self-contained. And that's just the reading comprehension. The idea that the math word problems involve cultural bias that would affect performance is utterly ridiculous. "Most studies"... there is no chance that any quality research has been done to support something so laughable. I will look at any citations you may have, but I am 100% confident that you have been duped.
- jedberg 5y agoHere is the main study from 2003: https://meridian.allenpress.com/her/article-abstract/73/1/1/31807/Correcting-the-SAT-s-Ethnic-and-Social-Class-Bias https://meridian.allenpress.com/her/article-abstract/73/1/1/... That 2003 study was done at Harvard. Here is a writeup of someone who replicated it with more recent test scores: https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2010/06/21/new-evidence-racial-bias-sat https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2010/06/21/new-evidence-...
- hcurtiss 5y ago"The SAT has been shown to be both culturally and statistically biased against . . . Asian Americans." Well, I'll be damned. Huh.
- civilized 5y agoFrom the second article: > The 2003 study and this year's found no DIF issues in the mathematics section. The earlier claim about math word problems being culturally biased seems unsupported by the citations. But will the claim be withdrawn? Hmm, let's find out...
- jedberg 5y agoHere is a simple example from an old SAT (1970s): Runner is to Marathon as XXXXXXXX is to Regatta If you grew up on the coast in a wealthy family, you have a much higher chance of knowing what a Regatta is and that it involves boat races.
- rayiner 5y agoThis is pissing on people's leg and telling them its raining. There's no "cultural loading" in the SATs. English is my second language and I didn't even know Chicago was a big city until my mid-20s, but reading a lot and practicing vocabulary words is easy and cheap. New York's Stuyvesant high school has an average SAT score of around 1500, and half of students are eligible for free/reduced price lunch: https://www.nydailynews.com/opinion/stuyvesant-serves-needy-minorities-article-1.3944199 https://www.nydailynews.com/opinion/stuyvesant-serves-needy-... Poverty makes things harder, no doubt. But American parenting is just bad and American students don't try very hard. My wife comes from a lower-income white family (multi-generational lack of economic mobility) and the lack of emphasis on eduction or discipline at home is glaring. Some people, like my wife, are just naturally very self-driven and make it out. But a lot of potential gets wasted because kids are allowed to just faff around instead of being rigidly guided by parents (or, as is more commonly the case, by the one parent).
- Kranar 5y agoSo then what do you make of the studies that show that SATs are culturally biased, like the one OP posted [1]. I decided to go ahead and buy it for the 10 bucks and review it. It's a surprisingly technical study that seems fairly robust and it has been replicated several times (original study in 2003 and replicated in 2010). The findings are that much of the disparity between minorities and whites goes away for harder analogies that are more technical or scientific in nature, in fact contrary to what I expected, the recommendation of the study is to simply eliminate the bottom third of verbal questions (ranked by difficulty) involving analogies or sentence completion, as those are the questions that are most likely to involve cultural bias. If my understanding is correct (and I'm sure I have some subtle details wrong), the idea is to let students take the SAT, then go over the verbal/analogy/sentence completion portion of the SAT and order each question by the proportion of white students who answered it correctly, and then eliminate the easiest of those questions from the final score. The most difficult questions are still part of the test, but apparently most of the cultural bias is among the easiest questions to answer that minorities get tripped up on. If your hypothesis were true, that it's mostly a matter of bad parenting, it's kind of hard to see why bad parenting would make minorities struggle to answer the easiest questions for white people, but not also struggle to answer the hardest questions as well. [1] https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2010/06/21/new-evidence-racial-bias-sat https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2010/06/21/new-evidence-...
- allturtles 5y agoThat appears to be a purely statistical argument - some questions appear to be disproportionately hard/easy for certain racial groups. That has some value, but it would be nice to see some concrete example(s) of how this bias is expressed.
- jedberg 5y agoI posted an example in a sibling comment: Runner is to Marathon as XXXXXXXX is to Regatta If you grew up on the coast in a wealthy family, you have a much higher chance of knowing what a Regatta is and that it involves boat races.
- civilized 5y agoAside from the fact, repeatedly pointed out, that the analogy section has been kaput since 2005... this would be a hard question, the sort that shows the least racial and income gaps.
- allturtles 5y agoAs I replied there, this example is very old. There hasn't even been an analogy section since 2005.
- civilized 5y agoDefinitely my most hated section. Full of rare, obscure, you-know-it-or-don't words for massive bookworms. But if you read the papers cited in the GGGP comment, those hard problems aren't the problems that show the racial gap. The hardest problems show the least gap. Which doesn't fit the pat little sailboat jargon theory at all. However it does fit a common pattern, also seen in longevity statistics, where the most exceptional are more similar to one another than the average are.
- DenisM 5y ago> the most exceptional are more similar to one another than the average are Wait, can you elaborate?
- WalterBright 5y ago> it is really a test of how wealthy you were growing up Incredible educational resources are available online for free and just a click away on that supercomputer in everyone's pocket. There's no reason to be restricted to your parents' vocabulary.