4 ms·
During the time of a polytheistic roman empire, Christianity was literally a cult, and an underground one at that. Judaism and the Roman pantheon had more adher
by ggm 5y ago
During the time of a polytheistic roman empire, Christianity was literally a cult, and an underground one at that. Judaism and the Roman pantheon had more adherents. Outside of the Roman controlled spaces, Zoroastrianism certainly did, as would Hindu and Buddhist faiths. Probably more Celtic believers.
The transition from cult to state church must have been tremendously affirming for some, but probably accepted with resignation by as many, for some time.
- AQuantized 5y agoThe rise of Islam was even more tremendous, beginning in Muhammad's 40th year when the archangel Gabriel first began communicating the Quran to him, and becoming the largest religion in Arabia by the time of Muhammad's death 22 years later.
- ggm 5y agoOne savage git fork and then only minor branches. It's like bsd4.4 morphing into net and free. (Sunni/Shia split)
- dhosek 5y agoThere are still plenty of Christians who rue the transition to state church, although they tend to be in the minority. You'll usually find them in the fringes in things like the Catholic Workers or the New Monasticism (which is sort of a protestant Catholic Worker movement). I'd assume that many Quakers also fit the mold.
- ggm 5y agoQuakers break the mould in more ways: they include the small subset of athiest quakers. Well, let's be polite. Nontheist. A charming church of scotland minister in fife told my athiest brother it was no barrier to a successful career in the church, one should not allow a trivial obsession with the 39 articles to stand in the way. He specialised in computer aided stylometry of amongst other writing, the Pauline epistles.
- dhosek 5y agoThere was a bit of a public debate a few years ago (maybe more than a few years ago) whether belief in God was necessary for Unitarianism. IIRC, there was a smallish schism as a result of the debate between the deists and atheists. From the little that I know of Quakerism, I would think that at least some level of deism would be necessary, but who knows. Graham Greene had a short story, “The Last Word,” (the title story of his final story collection) which posited a world in which atheism had become nearly universal and the military dictator summoned the last believer, the Pope who had become senile with age to assassinate him. After shooting him, he began to have doubts about his atheism and faith continued.
- andrepd 5y agoThe last paragraph reminds me of this https://www.jstor.org/stable/27899562 https://www.jstor.org/stable/27899562
- ggm 5y agoThank you for a fascinating reference. That's on my backlist to read now.