4 ms·
It also sounds like they’d need proof they colluded with a foreign entity which is a very high bar.
by dmix 5y ago
It also sounds like they’d need proof they colluded with a foreign entity which is a very high bar.
- colinmhayes 5y ago> Those seeking to deny those rights to others I'd say harassment falls into this category, so no proof of collusion with the CCP is needed.
- lazide 5y agoIf something is harassment or merely exercising their right to express their opinion is also a matter for subjective judgement and he said/she said type finger pointing, and highly dependent on context and frequency (which can be hard to find solid concrete evidence for without a lot of work).
- simonh 5y agoIt sounds like some of the students not only threatened to report him to the Chinese authorities, but told him that they had done so, and he has proof who made these threats and claims. They didn’t try to hide it.
- lazide 5y agoIf they have a right to do that, is that harassment? I doubt Purdue (up to now) has any policy saying it’s illegal to report someone to authorities for something they did. Even if those authorities are not popular right now and the thing they did is ok at Perdue but not at home. Is it a ‘dick move’ and offend our sensibilities? Sure. But that doesn’t mean it’s any different than if a bunch of folks from the US were at a French university during the 50’s and someone called the FBI telling them that Bob was saying a lot of scary things about communism and just got a Russian Girlfriend and maybe they should look into it. If it’s true, then of course the FBI is going to look into it. If true, it’s also unlikely to count as harassment. It’s also pretty terrible from 5 different angles.
- ralmidani 5y agoPeople have been expelled from universities for videos where they used the N-word. I agree with imposing that consequence (unless it was in the distant past and the student has since shown genuine rehabilitation). Reporting someone to a regime which tortures, kills, and harvests the organs of dissenters is orders of magnitudes worse than using a racist slur.
- lazide 5y agoI agree with you, but the Chinese government doesn’t, and they have a long reach. One we are free to ignore, but others seem hesitant to.
- strathmeyer 5y ago
- lazide 5y agoRead my comment above - I’m warning people that they’re being naive if they think it’s as clear cut as they think or this student isn’t pretty screwed for many reasons, regardless of how the rest of this turns out.
- ivalm 5y agoPurdue certainly has policy against harassment. Other students followed and directly harassed, Purdue is not the government so it doesn’t even need to weigh free speech or legality.
- BrazzVuvuzela 5y ago> If they have a right to do that, is that harassment? Yes. Having the right to say or do something doesn't mean it isn't harassment. But more importantly, the 'students' making these reports/threats are acting as agents of the CCP, projecting the CCP's power into an American university, and should be ejected from the country for that. What they were doing was espionage.
- wbsss4412 5y ago
- Larrikin 5y agoEven a public university can decide what they want to do when it comes to punishment for students they admit. You aren't owed an explanation no matter how much you pretend on the internet to care.
- fallingknife 5y agoA public university has to respect the constitutional rights of it's students though. So there would be very strong legal protection for pro China students. Edit: actually not sure if they are foreign nationals. Maybe someone knows if same applies?
- gameswithgo 5y agoPeople have no problem bending the rules to punish people swiftly if it benefits them. It is only when it would be painful to do the right thing that people insist on their legal limitations.
- jakeinspace 5y agoThe student's citizenship makes no difference legally when it comes to First Amendment privileges.
- ivalm 5y ago> constitutional rights This is a false statement. The only regulation here is title VI and title IX. The administration of a public university is not legally part of the government.
- stale2002 5y ago> The administration of a public university is not legally part of the government. Nope, you are wrong. There have literally been supreme court cases about free speech rights of students. And yes, the supreme court has found that it is possible for a public school to break the 1st amendment rights of students.
- nouveaux 5y ago