3 ms·
> It has been said that non-programmers used to catch on to APL quite quickly back in the day Thompson and Ritchie also said their secretaries happily wrote tr
by Someone 5y ago
> It has been said that non-programmers used to catch on to APL quite quickly back in the day
Thompson and Ritchie also said their secretaries happily wrote troff.
Do people get pampered too much today or are we severely underestimating them?
- Jtsummers 5y agoI think we underestimate them, but they also underestimate themselves (I hear a lot of "I can't..." by people who definitely can, once that word is in their head they no longer can but because of the mental block). Also, there was a major difference between what the secretaries would have been using before troff and their experience with troff. In particular, at that time, they were probably using typewriters. A digital workflow would have been a massive improvement in experience. Need multiple copies? No more carbon copies or retyping, now it just comes off the printer (which may still use a carbon copy, but at least you don't have to retype it). Need to adjust something? At least for future printouts it's just changing the file, and maybe using whiteout and handwriting the correction in a few printouts. Want to reflow the entire page? On a typewriter you start over, with troff you edit. Today, people have Word and Google Docs, why do they need troff/Markdown/TeX/LaTeX/Asciidoc/org-mode/etc.? The experience, for the user, is not as qualitatively different as those secretaries would have experienced at the time. Not just secretaries, my parents (a pilot and an engineer) took to computers in the 1970s (in college)/1980s (work, later home) for the same reason, it was a better experience than using typewriters and hand calculating things (even with a calculator).
- TheMonarchist 5y ago> Today, people have Word and Google Docs, why do they need troff/Markdown/TeX/LaTeX/Asciidoc/org-mode/etc.? Because what they write has structure and they don't want to be distracted by the looks.
- Jtsummers 5y agoJust saw your reply, but I think you're missing my point and I'm not sure if it's willful or not. If not, here it is again: The difference in experience between Word/Docs and the various text-based markup languages is not as significant as the difference that someone would have experienced going from a typewriter to something digital, whether troff or anything else. It is like trying to get someone to go from Excel -> another programming language, versus a handheld calculator and pen and paper to anything on a computer. There are differences, I'm not saying there aren't and you're being obtuse if that's how you're taking it, but the magnitude is far less. Regarding your "don't want to be distracted", Word has had an outline mode since at least 1995 (first time I used Word). Not sure about Google Docs, but it's a perfectly fine distraction free writing environment. So that's not even a selling point for users of Word.
- TheMonarchist 5y ago> I think you're missing my point I just don't object to anything but that one question. > Word has had an outline mode since at least 1995 I haven't had Word for years so I can't check it out, but if you take WYSIWYG out of a WYSIWYG editor, what is left? Why would I use it instead of other tools you listed? I have used some of them.
- t-3 5y agoTo be fair, troff was designed when typewriters were ubiquitous and is basically a direct analogue. It's not going to be hard for a professional typist (ie. secretary) to learn troff. It's like teaching R to a statistician.