4 ms·
Just like YC is equalizing informational asymmetry between twenty-something founders and people with signatory authority on hundreds of millions, I'm really gla
by patio11 15y ago
Just like YC is equalizing informational asymmetry between twenty-something founders and people with signatory authority on hundreds of millions, I'm really glad that HN contributes to education of prospective employees like this.
I like to think I'm smart. Two years ago, prior to HNducation, many common-as-dirt features of cap tables like e.g. liquidation preferences would have been a totally successful ambush on me. (If you can't explain three ways why 2% of $40 million is zero, consider carefully whether your best interests are being represented in a negotiation with someone who can.)
- japhyr 15y agoHow is 2% of $40 million zero?
- troels 15y agoIf investors hold $40m in preference, it's 0. But I'd be interested in the other two ways?
- mgkimsal 15y agoIs this was a record company deal, they'd have advanced you some goodwill and charged you for it. You'd be lucky to get out with $0, instead of owing them money for having worked there :)
- 3pt14159 15y agoDifferent classes of shares, liquidation preference, the IP being in a separate company that leases it to the company that you own the shares in, performance clauses (company needs to earn 2x revenue over the next 2 years).
- patio11 15y agoThree options: 1) Liquidation preferences. 2) "We wipe out common stock at acquisition and offer employees retention bonuses, leaving 2% owner who moved on totally shafted." 3) Pretend your corporate charter is a Ruby program and a malicious adversary gets write access to it. Seriously, the sky's the limit. Integers might be kitten pictures now, and multiplication returns shades of pink.
- throwaway96 15y ago1) Liquidation preferences: Right, and part of the problem is that as more investments are collected, more preferred shares get in line ahead of employees' common shares. "Down" rounds tend to devastate the value of common shares. But the good news is that upper management and regular employees are in principle affected the same way by these vicissitudes, and in practice I've seen that mostly happen. Some exceptions include founders/upper-management getting special opportunities to cash out or receiving significant anti-dilutive share bonuses. I'm not saying that the founders and employees have exactly the same incentives here, but they are at least somewhat helpfully aligned. 2) Agree that I've heard gossip about these kinds of scenarios, but (I've often wondered) wouldn't this be a violation of their fiduciary duty to certain stockholders? Can a lawyer weigh in on whether (in theory) this scenario allows for a legal remedy? 3) True, the corporate charter is not a contract with an employee, and it can be rewritten at will by the Board. But it seems to me there are limits: if they edit the charter in a way that deliberately wipes out the value of your shares and had a choice not to, this resembles case 2, where I suspect one can seek legal redress (right?).
- ootachi 15y agoIronically, this particular information dispersal is directly contrary to the interests of YC -- it is in founders' and investors' best interests to drive the employee option pool as close to 0% as possible, without communicating that fact to employees.
- patio11 15y agoI'd be inclined to trust YC that they make their money by picking AirbnBoxen rather than chiseling twenty somethings out of a few thousand bucks. Even if I were cynical regarding their motivations, I would personally take a YC investment as a Good Housekeepng Seal of "will probably not pull sociopathic moves.". My theory: founders only need to exit once and might be tempted to get screwtastic. VCs face no market penalty for screwing employees because a) employees have severe information asymmetry when it comes to deciding who to work for based on investors, b) the Valley practices institutional omertà about speaking ill of fellow investors except over backchannel, and c) a reputation for chiseling out employees doesn't hurt VCs at their main opportunity for market feedback: seeking LP. By comparison, YC is an early employee-comprehensible brand, and I'd expect anyone contemplating screwage would hear "You are about to chill hiring at several hundred companies in the mafia. Are you sane?! Don't do this. If you insist on doing this, we'll be forced to very publicly disassociate ourselves from your decision. You do not want to be the one ex-mafia guy in the Valley. It is a lonely place."
- dcposch 15y agoCounterpoint: sometimes regular employees do great. An older (~now 35-ish) acquaintance of mine made near-FU money from Amazon.com. He was an English major fresh out of college, started at Amazon when it was still a startup; his jobs were _reviewing books and doing secretary stuff + odd jobs_. Lots of talk here about the myriad ways employees can get screwed, but sometimes they do great. Another awesome company? Linear Tech. Not quite a startup anymore, but they do a lot of hardcore analog+digital EE design. Their engineers get design ownership over specific projects/chip designs, and are paid _a percentage of profits_ on that chip. So there are a substantial number of regular employees there who are millionaires because they designed something cool.