3 ms·
How much more value? Suppose men were providing $10 in additional value over the time they work for you. That's barely even worth a Starbucks gift card, the so
by tialaramex 5y ago
How much more value?
Suppose men were providing $10 in additional value over the time they work for you. That's barely even worth a Starbucks gift card, the sort of thing you probably give away to people who guess the number of marbles in a jar at a company mandatory fun event. You definitely shouldn't hire James rather than Deborah because of an average $10 gender difference unless they are literally interchangeable. If their sole distinguishing feature was somehow that Deborah's smile was nicer, or James' laugh was more annoying, that's probably still enough difference to out-weigh this $10 lifetime value. And the reality is your candidates just aren't that similar. Deborah's six years experience in a similar role while James is applying with no relevant background should not lead to the conclusion that all that matters is the average "value once hired" for James will be higher based on gender averages.
Now, suppose women are providing $10M in additional value. Well, I think we'd have noticed something that dramatic by now right? "Gee, my start-up with five women broke even in the first six weeks because of how awesome women are". So we can rule that sort of large figure out as implausible.
I think a discussion about whether it's reasonable needs to take the magnitude of the difference into consideration, which would first mean (if you wanted to do this) finding out for sure how large that difference even is. My guess is, if you did this, you get a very small answer and so then the discussion is really easy: No.
But before you could do that, you'd need to have a decent objective measurement of this "value once hired", and that part is far harder so it won't get done.
- newsclues 5y agoIf you are in a gunfight, would you rather have a slight advantage? You also need to consider the risks and circumstances, sometimes you want every tiny edge possible.
- tialaramex 5y agoSure, you spend as long as you like figuring out how best to achieve the slight advantage, meanwhile I shoot you in the head. Analysis paralysis, figuring out what to do costs time and time is expensive so you should avoid this unless you've got a good reason to expect it actually matters and you believe you can actually do it correctly.
- vidarh 5y agoThe problem with this is that it presumes you know which actually has an advantage in that scenario to within the error margins. In the $10 example, I'd argue chances are very small that you actually know who provides the most value because just a tiny shift in the measurement criteria could shift things in the other direction. If such a tiny edge matters, it's an indicator you have a problem.
- dasil003 5y agoNot to mention someone’s value ends up varying based on what they are assigned to and who they work with. Frankly the whole idea of precisely measuring individual value is bean-counting bullshit.