9 ms·
Refugees lack Covid shots because drugmakers fear lawsuits, documents show
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- walterbell 5y ago> Many COVID-19 vaccine manufacturers have required that countries indemnify them for any adverse events suffered by individuals as a result of the vaccines, the United Nations says. Where governments are not in control, that is not possible. The concerns affect people, such as those displaced by the Myanmar, Afghanistan and Ethiopian crises, who are beyond the reach of national governments' vaccination schemes. Stateless humans have more legal protection than stateful humans?
- JetAlone 5y agoThat's a good question with a lot of observations that could be made... I'd say that out of concern for the (economic) consequences of harmful side effects, the choice not to get the jab is de-facto forcefully made for the stateless by the manufacturers + state. I wouldn't call this protection. As a stateless, your legal freedom (which I think ought to be inalienable) to get a particular medical product you might want is not protected because protection of the corporate manufacturer's bottom line has priority. The manufacturers are carefully avoiding the one thing they _don't_ want which would be indemnifying individual sufferers of side effects from their bottom line. They do this by either having the people effectively indemnify themselves by paying them from their own people's money through the government, or by refusing to give it to anyone not indemnified this way. Basically, the manufacturers want riskless profit for rolling this product out, one way or another. The manufacturers will do what it takes to exercise a privilege they think ought to be inalienable, that being to help themselves our collective wealth so long as we use their product, whatever it is.
- jktogjfnn 5y agoBut think about how we got here. In US you can get 100 mil in liability damages per injured person in lawsuits, which doesn't make any sense when you consider that with that sum you could save thousands of lives (poor people, ...) So you could easily be made to pay 10 bil for causing vaccine damage to a 1000 people, while disregarding the hundred of millions the vaccine saved. Do you think that would be fair?
- JetAlone 5y agoI'd have to ask, do liability damages have to be 100 mil per person? Why can't they be significantly less, IE more commensurate to a reasonable (surely never 100% accurate) assessment of the rough economic value of damages actually inflicted? If we cannot save millions of lives with meds without the following drawbacks: -Inadequate recourse for many of those suffering harmful side effects. -The effective re-distribution of the people's wealth to the harmed individual to spackle over the damage should harmful effects occur. -Infringing on the rights of human beings to prevent them from taking medical procedures they want to preserve corporate bottom lines. Then beyond it being fair for a vaccine company to go under, I believe it would be just for the entire legal and civic system to collapse to be rebuilt by a structure that respects both human liberty and dignity. I believe it's a cycle that will happen again and again, every time, until we get it right and can finally keep millions of people safe enough to living meaningful enough lives without trampling their rights and without encouraging them to become too weak to preserve them. And further, I don't think we're ever actually going to get it right as a species, so things like this are going to happen, once in a long lifetime.
- willcipriano 5y agoWithout a vaccine mandate I can see your argument, however if you force people to take a drug you have decided to take ownership of the situation. In that case you are responsible for the outcome. If you don't want to be responsible for a choice, don't make it.
- JetAlone 5y ago
- aa-jv 5y ago>Stateless humans have more legal protection than stateful humans? "If there is hope, it may lie with the proles..."
- lmm 5y agoStateless people are (generally) difficult for governments to impose on but have little governmental support. I'd say it tends to be a negative on net, though I guess that depends on your views on government in general.
- walterbell 5y agoPerhaps they need the right lawyers or agents.
- lmm 5y agoWhat could a lawyer or agent do? Being stateless means you don't have the rights or the obligations of citizenship, more or less by definition.
- walterbell 5y agoThen there's no need for Pharma company lawyers to be concerned about liability. Yet they are? > where those applying for doses, mainly NGOs, can't bear legal risks, deliveries from that stockpile can only be made if vaccine-makers accept liability.
- lmm 5y agoIf you injure another person you're liable for corresponding damages, that's not a function of citizenship. Nations are willing to assume liability for vaccine side effects suffered by their citizens (which is something that requires resources beyond what an individual could put up - consider the possibility of e.g. becoming paralysed and requiring life-long round-the-clock care). The problem that stateless people have (in this context) is that they don't have a nation-like organisation that will do that for them.
- hetspookjee 5y agoSo these companies get swaths of subsidies. They get price agreements with the liberty to bump it with double digit percentages. They get waivers for any and all responsibilities and orders en masse. Yet helping the hopeless and poor is too much to ask in fear of lawsuits. What a shameful situation.
- hmmmcurious1 5y agoWhy do they waive responsibility though
- artificialLimbs 5y agoIt is not possible to sue vaccine manufacturers if you are injured/killed. You (or your family if you are killed) have to go to a special court and very likely lose your case. In the unlikely event you win, the government pays you, not the manufacturers.
- jgod 5y agoHow do I get the same thing going for my software? That is, to get it mandated or legislated that people have to buy it (preferably multiple times: subscription). And no matter what happens, I can't be held liable or pay damages. Sounds like a very solid business model.
- bostik 5y agoBecome an AV vendor. A good one. Entire sections of business are (for all intents and purposes) legally required to run up-to-date AV products on all their Windows endpoints.
- lmm 5y agoYou mean a good one in regard to the business, right? Because that seems to have very little to do with producing a good AV product.
- KennyBlanken 5y ago> Johnson & Johnson (JNJ.N) of the United States confirmed it would waive a requirement for indemnity for deliveries from the buffer: "We are proud to be part of this effort to protect the world's most vulnerable people," said Paul Stoffels, Vice Chairman of the Executive Committee and Chief Scientific Officer. He did not elaborate. The maker of the most dangerous-side-effect-laden vaccine available being willing to waive liability really takes the wind out of the sails of other drug companies claiming the liability burden is too great.
- ars 5y agoIt's because the side effects are known, and the patient is warned about them - so they can't sue for that.
- refurb 5y agoThis is not true. Side effects are not binary (you get them of you don’t). A manufacturer could say “you run the risk of temporary paralysis of no longer than 1 year” (based on observations to date), then patient has paralysis lasting 2 years so they sue because “manufacturer understated risk and severity of paralysis”.
- dmz73 5y agoGovernments are also indemnifying the people who do not want to get the vaccines and are spreading covid through their behavior (no masks, not distancing, no isolating). It would be interesting to see what would happen if families of people that die from covid-19 in coming months/years bring a negligent homicide lawsuits against some of the prominent advocates of the above mentioned behavior.
- Madmallard 5y agoPeople generally don't expose themselves around others while obviously sick. In the case that the transmissions happen it's likely not a case you can pursue in court.
- native_samples 5y agoGiven that vaccines don't affect transmission at all, but do suppress symptoms, any such lawsuits would run in the other direction - people who can't take the vaccines due to allergies etc suing people who did, on the grounds that they knew or should have known that they'd become invisible spreaders and dangerous to those who couldn't take vaccines. But in reality no sensible court would allow such arguments in either direction. Trying to assign moral culpability to an invisible body state you can't sense is idiotic and dystopian.
- dkjaudyeqooe 5y ago> Given that vaccines don't affect transmission at all That is false. Stop spreading dangerous nonsense. https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20211124-vaccines-reduce-covid-transmission-by-40-who https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20211124-vaccines-redu... https://www.newscientist.com/article/2294250-how-much-less-likely-are-you-to-spread-covid-19-if-youre-vaccinated/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/2294250-how-much-less-l...
- native_samples 5y agoYou cite, I cite, we all cite ... https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanepe/article/PIIS2666-7762(21)00258-1/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanepe/article/PIIS2666-7... ... but who's right? If vaccines really affected transmission a lot, we'd see it in drastically reduced case numbers. What we actually see is that post-vaccination case numbers reach record highs. That should be a pretty basic reality check on any claims that transmission is heavily affected. Either that, or you have to believe transmissibility has no impact on case numbers. What you tend to see is that studies that are older or use older data conclude more effectiveness. The New Scientist article you cite presents evidence from a study that used data only pre-Delta. But the point people are making when they say it doesn't affect transmission is about the current state of play. Not the situation back in March two major mutations ago.
- sonicggg 5y agoI see a lot of complaints of people about the fact that Pfizer required legal immunity against side effects. This is a must for any vaccine manufacturer, otherwise the vaccine is just not commercially feasible. That's what killed Lymerix, and why we don't have Lyme disease vaccine anymore. If the government does not back it up, the manufacturer won't stand a chance. Even if the vaccine has a good safety profile, a 0.1% rate of side effects applied to millions is still a lot of lawsuits.
- fsh 5y agoThis also happened with the DPT vaccine in the 1980s. Manufacturers kept losing lawsuits based on junk science until they could no longer afford liability insurance. This is why the US congress passed the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act that protects manufacturers from lawsuits.
- roenxi 5y agoThat is a signal your laws are bad and squelching valuable innovation. Giving random one-off exceptions when you personally feel like it is a terrible way to regulate commerce. Vendors should be able to grade their vaccines on a curve based on how much safety and efficacy data there is, then let people choose whatever in consultation with their doctors.
- jimmyearlcarter 5y agoexactly
- evandijk70 5y agoPlease note that for a vaccine against a disease like corona, a 0.1% rate of side effects serious enough to lead to lawsuits is not a 'good safety profile', especially when given to people outside well-defined risk groups. The Johnson & Johnson and Astrazeneca vaccines, which probably have a 'borderline safety profile' have a rate of side-effects between 0.001% and 0.0001%.
- ajsnigrutin 5y ago
- throw8932894 5y agoWell, kick them out then. Refuses to sign a waiver and get shot? Asylum denied! My government demands vaccinations under heavy fines. Unvaccinated people can not even enter country. Why should anyone be treated differently? It is question of life and death after all.
- nfreising 5y agoHave you read the article? This is not about people not willing to get vaccinated but about pharmaceutical companies wanting legal protection by a government authority. Also this seems to affect mostly displaced people in poorer countries (e.g. Afghan refugees in Iran), which is not comparable to asylum seekers in your (I suppose rather wealthy) home country.
- walterbell 5y agoOct 2021, https://www.citizen.org/article/pfizers-power/ https://www.citizen.org/article/pfizers-power/ > Public Citizen has identified several unredacted Pfizer contracts that ... offer a rare glimpse into the power one pharmaceutical corporation has gained to silence governments, throttle supply, shift risk and maximize profits in the worst public health crisis in a century. We describe six examples from around the world below.