4 ms·
This writeup is to be commended for courage and initiative, but to this reader falls terribly in the wisdom category > attempt and inability to empathize with
by mistrial9 5y ago
This writeup is to be commended for courage and initiative, but to this reader falls terribly in the wisdom category
> attempt and inability to empathize with the model
> watch the tree frog jump with excitement
> intimacy with the model ?!?
my feedback on this essay is that I needed many, many years of psychological study, mindfulness practice and real-life relationship experience to untangle my youthful spirit of life from my intellectual interests. I see both joy and tragedy in mixing your maths and your hormones. The metaphors of insight here are just not mixable, and I believe you are not alone in that.
- balsam 5y agoTo paraphrase the Lady Jessica, perhaps: All great problems of ML can never be solved; they can only be outgrown. EDIT: mentat learning>>machine learning??!!
- quickthrower2 5y agoMaybe using empathy for logical problems is akin to using GPU for computations. Maybe there are some problems it just solves well even though it wasn’t necessarily designed/evolved for that initially. See also people who solve problems in their dreams/subconscious/downtime.
- nyanpasu64 5y agoWhen learning, extending, or fixing software, I generally work by building an understanding of software's principles, implementation, and runtime behavior, so I can reason about the current state and the effects of potential changes. Though sometimes I tweak code to see the effects and better understand the problem (shh we don't talk about tweaking things until they "work on my machine" and we're done). Understanding runtime behavior is easier in software with high debuggability and transparency (which is orthogonal or even opposed to performance, since logging slows programs down and optimizations impede debugging). Bryan Cantrill's "Platform as a Reflection of Values" talk (https://vimeo.com/230142234 https://vimeo.com/230142234) has a list of software values. I think "observability" is another good word for what I want, but it tends to be thrown around in cloud-scale software rather than the human-scale software I prefer. Perhaps "empathy" is a workable word for developing an intuition (and less so for building a mental model).
- specialist 5y agoMaintaining someone else's code, I'm equal parts mind reader, software archeologist, detective (forensics), and grumpy old man. When I've had to maintain ML stuff, I spent most of my time wrestling with the tools and chaotic mutant one-off instances of "data pipelines", contorting myself into the mindset of the creators. So, ya, "empathy" works for me. FWIW, I found the tools like PyTorch, Spark, and such to be laughable bad. I pity the people who have to do this work on the daily. Jupyter is cool though.