3 ms·
"Meritocracy does exist and does work, except where it is undermined (i.e. "Equity" You really pick 'equity' as the example? I get thats it fashionable to hate
by ClumsyPilot 5y ago
"Meritocracy does exist and does work, except where it is undermined (i.e. "Equity"
You really pick 'equity' as the example? I get thats it fashionable to hate on woke politics around these parts, but aren't your forgeting that most of the world is more like Russia, i.e. jungle, where stongest rules because they can, with mirderous intent.
I mean if you are talking about principles of life, its got to be universal, not just applying in a handfull of fortunate countries.
The principles of we go by, they are in conflict with one another.
- kerneloftruth 5y agoThe point is that Equity undermines Meritocracy -- and you can say the same in reverse. They are mutually exclusive concepts. I'll repeat from my reply above: Hiring, raises, and promotions should not be based on skin color, eye color, gender, or other immutable traits. In a meritocracy, these are instead determined _solely_ by how provably capable a person is (per Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.'s prescription). Slathering on a layer of "but we want to contrive a correction to history, and institute racial discrimination as a remedy to past racial discrimination" undermines the weight of merit, and creates new harm to individuals and society. Per Dr. King, a meritocracy is the correct solution. Two wrongs do not make a right.