3 ms·
Is that correct? Let's say Bill was born here on Earth on August 26, 2011, "at the same time" astronomers first detected this supernova. On Earth, we observe Bi
by baddox 15y ago
Is that correct? Let's say Bill was born here on Earth on August 26, 2011, "at the same time" astronomers first detected this supernova. On Earth, we observe Bill's birth and the beginning of the supernova to be simultaneous events. However, isn't it true that an observer at the supernova (presuming he could survive) wouldn't agree that Bill's birth and the supernova were simultaneous, would he?
- mhb 15y agoHe would because he knows how fast information travels.
- ars 15y ago> On Earth, we observe Bill's birth and the beginning of the supernova to be simultaneous events. No, that is incorrect. We observe that the light from the supernova reached us now, yes. But we are well aware that it actually happened long ago. Both us and the distant observer agree about the order and relative timing of the events. It's only when we are not in the same frame of reference that we would disagree, and that is not the case here.