4 ms·
50K users is a drop in the bucket. The issues are: * Can MetaFace reliably detect such bad actors? * Is their current technology, where users don't control th
by wolverine876 5y ago
50K users is a drop in the bucket. The issues are:
* Can MetaFace reliably detect such bad actors?
* Is their current technology, where users don't control their own data, compatible with protecting users privacy? In other words, isn't this exactly where we expected to end up when these technologies were first built?
* How can we trust that they don't just ban the ones they don't like and leave users to the mercies of the others?
- GhettoComputers 5y agoDo you already know the answer to that? They can and choose not to, someone used their own 2012 tools they developed in a scientific paper (detection of Nazis) Nobody controls their own data, it’s not FB it’s all data mined. How can you trust Facebook? I refuse to use their rebrand, you don’t give trust, they earn it. Did Facebook earn your trust? The proof they can detect is is they use it to advertise. https://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-tn-facebook-nazi-metal-ads-20190221-story.html https://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-tn-faceboo... Nazis are pretty easy to detect (caste discrimination can be trained, anti Muslim sentiments are easy too, but this is a low hanging fruit). Like Leary said, do they care? Facebook obviously can do it, they’d rather sell ads and use the users as marketing data instead of removing them, until they need to virtue signal. I can’t find the paper but I doubt anything I said is a surprise. These tools are used to make money, not moderate.
- JetAlone 5y agoI wonder how often if ever extreme groups eager to recruit use the ads served to them as a source of potential "proto-shibboleths" to look into. If the advertisers with their dearth of data could know, before even you do, what sort of stuff people like you tend to like, you could use them as a bleeding edge to go to events/locations associated with that thing to meet fellow sympathizers who could potentially be activated, or unmet fellow activists who just happened to be around.
- FridayoLeary 5y agoThere's an even bigger issue *Do they actually care? I think the answer is obvious given facebooks business model. The only issue is competition.
- bostonsre 5y agoI doubt they care about solving it completely, but publicizing this is definitely good PR for them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- chiefalchemist 5y agoCan you give an example of "the ones they don't like"? FB is in the data harvesting and aggregation business. Anyone using their data - without reciprocity - is unwelcomed. Full stop. We're not users to FB anymore than a cow is family to a milk farmer. Of course they'll protect the farm, not because they're benevolent, but simply because it keeps the milk flowing and that product pays the bills.
- shakna 5y ago> Can you give an example of "the ones they don't like"? FB is in the data harvesting and aggregation business. Anyone using their data - without reciprocity - is unwelcomed. Full stop. Cambridge Analytica comes to mind. Facebook actively assisted them. Though the scandal caused many, many policy changes at Facebook, it is a historical case of Facebook assisting someone using their data to spy on their users.
- chiefalchemist 5y agoI don't think CA was a liked, per se. FB needed a success story (of sorts). Without that the strength of the product would be suspect. As it is, CA's affect on the election isn't proven. That said, perception is reality. FB got the better end of the deal.
- shakna 5y ago> As it is, CA's affect on the election isn't proven. That's fairly irrelevant to the topic at hand, without saying anything about it, one way or the other. Facebook has given away their data in the past, and gone so far as to provide special access for some clients over others. That is undisputed. There's no reason to believe that they may not do so again, in future, if they believe it to be in their interests.
- chiefalchemist 5y agoGive away? Nothing is free. FB isn't in the donation business. There might not have been a transparent financial transaction, but that's not a proxy for "given away." We're discussing FB, not the local pizza shop. Let's be realistic about their power and how they operate, etc.
- croes 5y agoIt is not the users' data but Facebook's data about the users. And Facebook doesn't protect the the users' privacy but its assets.