8 ms·
cough national id scheme, anyone? Thinking of E-Estonia here.
by pjc50 5y ago
cough national id scheme, anyone? Thinking of E-Estonia here.
- chrisin2d 5y agoI lived in the Netherlands and admired how they offer a SSO service called DigiD for most—if not all—national and municipal services: personal tax, business tax, healthcare, pension, water, garbage, police and many other service portals. Yes, there is a nice online police portal where you can digitally file a police report, get a declaration for insurance, and ask questions. You also get a digital inbox—Berichtenbox—to organize and centralize all communications from those agencies. It is difficult to overstate how much life is made better when the government is well-organized and that organization is exposed to you through good UX. I'm now back in the US, it's been 2+ weeks since my renewed passport was supposed to have been mailed to me, and no one at the State Department knows anything.
- dzhiurgis 5y agoNot having to depend on phone numbers would be so good, especially for citizen mobility.
- jjcm 5y agoIt's long, long overdue. That said a national ID scheme has long been opposed by a vocal part of the Christian population in the states. It's association with the new testament's prophesy of the mark of the beast prevents many lawmakers from pushing forward a proposal, especially since 65% of Americans in 2019 identified as having a belief in some variety of Christianity[0]. The obvious reality here is that in the wake of no proper national identification system, social security numbers have been used instead. It's not a question of whether or not we have a national ID, it's really just a question of whether we have a functional one or an inadequate one. Nonetheless politicians would likely be committing suicide with their constituents in some districts if they were to support a push towards a better system. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_the_United_States#:~:text=The%20United%20States%20has%20been,26%25%20of%20the%20total%20population https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_the_United_States#....
- ghaff 5y ago>social security numbers have been used instead Historically that was sort of the case. I'd argue today that we mostly rely on state-issued IDs (especially but not necessarily driver's licenses) which are now overlaid with RealID requirements. As a practical matter it's probably indistinguishable from what a federally-issued ID would be and I'm mostly content with not adding any more layers of identity verification than are really necessary. I'd probably oppose a push for a broadly required federal ID--although I have a passport (and a global entry card).
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoSome states allow use of SSNs for drivers license numbers.
- ghaff 5y agoIt’s generally decreased over time though.
- OrsonSmelles 5y ago>RealID requirements This doesn't invalidate your point, but man it irritates me how many states have chosen to retain a noncompliant ID tier in order to avoid eating costs or raising fees. At least my state offers a full EDL so there's some added value, but it's absurd that the 'default' local ID isn't adequate for domestic air travel.
- ghaff 5y agoThere are non-trivial documentation requirements for RealID though. I had to go back in a second time. If someone has no need to fly it’s probably reasonable to offer them a lower bar.
- ahazred8ta 5y agoThere's a surprising number of people who do not possess a birth certificate document. Their parents lost it, it got thrown out during an eviction, etc, etc. I've witnessed people at DMV stations who brought in their original birth certificates, but the embossed notary stamp had flattened over the years. It takes time and money to get a replacement. If the non-enhanced IDs didn't exist, these people couldn't get a state id card.
- dzhiurgis 5y agoMy National ID is valid for 10 years, but certificates expire 3 years after issue. Can only renew face to face, but I’m approx 30hours of flight time away from home, lol. But I agree - NFC passports are already kinda doing that, but there isn’t enough services that support it.
- miohtama 5y agoThis is the US we are talking about. Must be against the constitution and government is bad. Better to live in perpetual fraud.
- psychlops 5y agoPeople will always live in perpetual fraud, it's only a matter of degree.