3 ms·
Consider the massive usage of Facebook and Twitter, the lack of outrage over the warrantless wiretapping scandal (running for 10.5 years now), easily available
by beagle3 15y ago
Consider the massive usage of Facebook and Twitter, the lack of outrage over the warrantless wiretapping scandal (running for 10.5 years now), easily available voter records (see e.g. the backstory behind Latanya Sweeney's original identifiability study), and lack of public comments about requiring ISPs to store all session information for a long time - I would say that is strong evidence that USA as a nation does not actually value privacy.
edit: wireless wiretapping scandal -> warrantless wiretapping scandal, silly me.
- Hawramani 15y agoOr the fact that all ATT (and possibly Verizon) traffic goes through the NSA.
- beagle3 15y agodoh! I wrote "wireless wiretapping scandal" but I meant "warrantless wiretapping scandal", which is what you are referring to explicitly. edited to note correction; Thanks!
- JoshTriplett 15y agoPlease don't equate a lack of change with a lack of outrage; that assumes we have the ability to fix things here just by getting outraged about them. I'd say "if only it were that easy", except that many of the broken things that need fixing exist due to supposed outrage/fear.
- beagle3 15y agoI use outrage as an indicator for the degree of caring (in the sense that "value privacy" means "care about privacy"); is that not an acceptable use?
- old-gregg 15y agoLack of outrage is the phenomena here, not the lack of respect for privacy. It's not that Americans don't value privacy, I think we do. Rather, it is the general attitude against outrage or, perhaps, against complaining, what differentiates the US from Europe. The country doesn't have a healthcare system for citizens outside of the military, and there's no outrage. Does this mean "there is strong evidence that USA as a nation" doesn't value not dying? "Don't seek government help, work harder, smile more and make more money" appears to be the answer/advice to those who complain/express outrage. Then you can buy yourself healthcare, privacy or anything you wish.
- beagle3 15y agoI beg to differ. You may tell that to yourself and feel better (and many Americans do), but in the grand scheme of actions-speak-louder-than-words world we live in, there is no evidence for the American respect for privacy. > Does this mean "there is strong evidence that USA as a nation" doesn't value not dying? No, but it does mean that the country does not value a social safety net as much as it values monetary profit for the few at the top of the healthcare insurance industry. > "Don't seek government help, work harder, smile more and make more money" appears to be the answer/advice to those who complain/express outrage. Then you can buy yourself healthcare, privacy or anything you wish. If you believe that, you are naive. Here are some facts for you (you can google them if you want, I don't have time) * 75% of people who file for bankruptcy because of medical expenses (and there are a lot of them) HAVE health care insurance. That doesn't happen in any country with socialized health care. * 40M americans are on food stamps; that is, they seek and receive government help, and unlike other government perks (like extended unemployment), these will never go away because that's what is stopping blood from flowing in the streets. * Senators and Congressmen are, on the average, millionaires (unlike military people). They can afford the healthcare they want. And they want state sponsored health care, for life (as long as they've served two terms); what's not good for the goose is apparently excellent for the gander. * The government takes money from you -- taxes -- essentially at gun point. You might believe it is only on income, but by debasing the currency (which the Fed has been doing very diligently since 2008, and slightly less diligently since 2000, and only just diligently since 1971), they rob the value of money you already have -- and if you hold only anything like gold that retains its value -- why, that's taxed as capital gains; you can't win. * What the government does with this money is -- among other things -- give it to their friends on Wall Street. To the tune of trillions of dollars. You know, I remember in 2004 I was arguing with an American friend about how americans can re-elect Bush, and his reply was "we're not stupid, it's just apathy". I see this apathy as stupidity. And you know what? It's not that it can't be changed. It's just the everyone prefers cheap iPods to actually facing things that matters. In general, that only delays the arrival of the bill - but it is coming.
- old-gregg 15y agoYou've written so many words I feel compelled to reply. Beagle, I am not arguing with you. Just pointing out that Americans aren't inclined to be outraged in general. Therefore you can't use the lack of outrage as a proof for anything, that's all.
- tonfa 15y ago> lack of public comments about requiring ISPs to store all session information for a long time Data retention is there since a long time in Europe...
- beagle3 15y agoIn some of the countries, not all of them (definitely not "for a long time"). But it is retained at the ISPs, with legally mandated security controls, except for government access. It would be better if they were not kept. As far as I know, the only privacy of records the US law cares about is health care records, through the HIPAA act.