5 ms·
> It’s daycare for the 80%. It’s not education. This is a popular trope heavily marketed in certain circles but it’s not even remotely true and it’s deeply dis
by acdha 5y ago
> It’s daycare for the 80%. It’s not education.
This is a popular trope heavily marketed in certain circles but it’s not even remotely true and it’s deeply disrespectful to the teachers working in an underfunded but critical position.
Beyond the obvious politics, the other thing to remember is that student performance very closely tracks the parents’ socioeconomic status. This is most known for explaining the gaps on international testing but it also leads to people misinterpreting school data and drawing the wrong conclusion. My son’s school is notably bimodal because it has both recent immigrants who tend to be poor and affluent professionals, and people sometimes look at the averages and conclude that the school is bad when it’s really just rediscovering that being poor in America sucks.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mannerheim 5y agoTeachers have earned every ounce of disrespect they receive.
- ZephyrBlu 5y agoI don't live in the US, but from seeing my brothers go through school it seems pretty true to me. Butts in seats matters more than students actually understanding the material.
- indymike 5y ago> This is a popular trope heavily marketed in certain circles but it’s not even remotely true and it’s deeply disrespectful to the teachers working in an underfunded but critical position. This is a quite shallow dismissal. I'm the father of five and my wife is a teacher. The truth is, many public schools have deteriorated into free day care, and the poorer the area the school serves, the more this rings true. > student performance very closely tracks the parents’ socioeconomic status. Perhaps, but this is often an urban/suburban issue where wealth is concentrated in a (usually) suburban school, and that in turn leads to the school being better resourced.
- acdha 5y agoI’m married to a teacher who’s taught at public and charter schools, mostly Title I. There are many areas they’d like to do better but I certainly haven’t seen anything which fits the unsourced “daycare” label and the other kids we know in, for example, a poor rural district also have not had that experience so I’d like some supporting evidence that this is a widespread problem.
- dolni 5y agoAdd me to the list. Just today my young lady was lamenting how she learns virtually nothing because disruptive kids ruin it for everyone else. That was also my experience growing up in school. And it was also my partner's. That is way too many experiences to dismiss.
- jtbayly 5y agoEh, the schools aren’t even effective daycare as far as I can tell. There’s no discipline. One of my teacher friends won’t send kids to the principal because it’s worse than doing nothing. She cares for the students. They are all very underprivileged. The school system is driving her out.
- neartheplain 5y ago>She cares for the students. They are all very underprivileged. The school system is driving her out. I've heard this from close friends and family who taught. All were teachers, all loved teaching, all taught underprivileged kids at challenging schools, and all of them quit teaching before turning 30. Each quit due to the lack of support they receieved from uncaring, petty, and inept school administrations. Teachers can't teach when they don't feel physically safe, or are abruptly reassigned to different classes mid-year, or know their performance evaluations will be sabotaged by jealous senior teachers or administrators who are poor performers themselves yet impossible to fire. These experiences took place in the US, both in large costal and small Midwestern urban school districts.
- clarkmoody 5y ago> underfunded Per-student spending has more than tripled since the 1960s and stands at over $15k/yr on average[1]. New York spends more than $38k/yr (!) per student, which boggles the mind. Of course, much of that money is absorbed in the ever-expanding bureaucracies of the system's program offices, services, departments, etc. Go find your local school district's website, download their most recent audit, and look at the proportion of employees who are teachers. When I performed the exercise, I found that fewer than 50% of employees were actually teachers. I think it's high time we started funding students, rather than systems. The last thing anybody needs is yet another hulking bureaucracy sucking the life force out of our institutions. [1]: https://www.publicschoolreview.com/average-spending-student-stats/national-data https://www.publicschoolreview.com/average-spending-student-...
- throwawaygh 5y agoWe're not spending $15K on every student. That's just the total spend divided by the number of students. In reality, we're spending substantially less than that on most students and substantially more than that on a small number of students with exceptional needs. > since the 1960s Right. The 60s. The 60s are ALWAYS used as the reference point in these conversations. Every. Single. Time. The ESEA, a cornerstone of the War on Poverty, was passed in 1965. Most other federal/state mandates that brought nearly everyone into the public education fold were passed after 1960. What it meant to educate the populace changed dramatically between 1960 and 1980. Huge swathes of people previously excluded were brought into the fold. Of course costs went up -- those people were excluded precisely because they're not the low-hanging cheap-to-educate fruit. > fewer than 50% of employees were actually teachers. Teachers are not the only class of employees who spend most/all of their time in direct contact with students. See above. I'm not interested in the percent of employees who are teachers. I'm interested in the percent of employees who are not either in direct contact with students or providing essential services (janitorial, transportation, food services, etc.)
- mannerheim 5y agoIn terms of education spending, the US spends more than ever other OECD country other than Luxembourg. The US spends an unusually large share on private education, but even public education expenditures are greater than that of the UK, France, Korea, and Japan, about the same as the Netherlands, and not that far behind Germany https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/sites/5e4ecc25-en/index.html?itemId=/content/component/5e4ecc25-en https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/sites/5e4ecc25-en/index.html?i...
- g42gregory 5y agoMy kids are going to school right now in CA. It does feels like a daycare. Core curriculum, such as Math and English, is being downgraded with a frightening pace. All we hear is SEL, SEL, SEL. I don’t need my kids to learn SEL. At this point, I fail to understand what schools actually do in California.