2 ms·
1) That isn't a loophole, but rather the usual state of affairs. Right now I can use rclone or similar piece of Free software with any cloud storage service, an
by mindslight 5y ago
1) That isn't a loophole, but rather the usual state of affairs. Right now I can use rclone or similar piece of Free software with any cloud storage service, and keep the contents of my files private. The cloud service has no access to the plaintext content, and thus can't be construed as having a duty to scan the plaintext. (If they were given notice that a specific blob was CSAM along with an encryption key that proved such, that's a different story)
2) If photos are accessible through iCloud web, then talking about encryption is irrelevant. That's just a standard cloud service which has the ability to scan on their servers. The Apple CSAM issue was remarkable precisely because Apple aimed to do the scanning on users devices before encryption that would make files unavailable through iCloud web.
3) Criminals still have rights. What we're talking about here is the right to computational representation.