4 ms·
> 6. Information wants to be protected. It's true that cyberspace and other recent developments are challenging our copyright laws and frameworks for protectin
by xg15 5y ago
> 6. Information wants to be protected.
It's true that cyberspace and other recent developments are challenging our copyright laws and frameworks for protecting intellectual property. The answer, though, is not to scrap existing statutes and principles. Instead, we must update old laws and interpretations so that information receives roughly the same protection it did in the context of old media. The goal is the same: to give authors sufficient control over their work so that they have an incentive to create, while maintaining the right of the public to make fair use of that information. In neither context does information want "to be free." Rather, it needs to be protected.
What I think this misses is that the progress of technology has it made impossible to go back to the status quo 40 years ago. Copyright seems like a reasonable middle-ground if works are mostly published on physical media which you can own, play whenever you want or even sell of give away - but which are relatively rarely copied.
In today's world, that option is gone - instead, we have two opposite extremes:
One is anarchy, in which a popular work will almost instantly be pirated and distributed all across the world
The other is DRM and complete control, in which the consumer does not own anything except an ephemeral license to consume a work. But the rights-holder can suddenly control exactly who may consume the work, when, how often, under which circumstances, what the may or may not otherwise do with the work, etc - and all those circumstances may change at a moment's notice. In extreme cases, the rights-holder may even revoke the license and effectively erase all copies of their work at once.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThere's a potential middle ground. - The present effective gate to the Internet is online service providers and mobile telephony / data providers. - A combination of UBI (sufficient to support authors, musicians, and other creators) and reputation / merit-based compensation (for works of more substantial effort, notably jouranlism, investigation, and research) should be able to support creatives. Note that this is more a career than strictly performance ("units moved") basis. People don't turn out substantial work consistently, and much of what's turned out on a consistent basis ... is less than substantial. - The "free Internet" already costs ~$800 billion/year, which divided amongst the roughly 1 billion inhabitants of North America and Europe (we'll include Japan and Australia by proxy) works out to ... $800/head, or $3,200 for a family of four, per year. That's the global advertising bill. And yes, it largely makes sense to allocate that amongst the OECD, the world's richest billion. - A small fraction of that would support all existing journalism, music, and publishing handsomly, as well as much television and video production. It's quite possible that there'd be some reallocation of compensation from the present mix. That might not be all bad. I've suggested this a few times: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26822263 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26822263 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26893033 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26893033
- canadaduane 5y agoI've largely come to the same conclusion. We want to support the creation of something that the physical universe treats as abundant and nearly infinite (information), but our economics are not currently aligned with possibilities that lead to win/win solutions for artists/consumers and the poor who often don't factor in to economic equations.
- ctdonath 5y agoNonsense. Never has everyone has more access, producing & receiving, whatever information they want - and nigh unto free. The issue isn’t cost, it’s inundation.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe mix is an issue. Much of what's freely-available is low-quality at best, propaganda (or worse) in the worst case. Curation itself has value, and yet is constrained. This is in fact a major theme of Andrew Shapiro's The Control Revolution, and one of the tired arguments still encountered frequently today which was entirely anticipated over two decades ago.
- ctdonath 5y agoCalories aren’t free. They’re not just there for the redistribution. What is one’s fair share of what another has worked to produce? Anyone can, for vanishingly low cost, distribute or access nearly any information they like. Yes, curation is important - and, like other work, has value worth trading for calories. Why the insistence on devaluing work, insisting the caloric cost of productivity not be compensated per its value to others?
- CRConrad 5y agoBut curation is the work nobody wants to pay for now, isn't it? "Calories" and "caloric cost" is a funny measure of value. Especially ironic given that from a nutritional perspective, they're what the poor get too much of and the rich do their best to avoid. In the information-nutritional world, dross ("empty calories") is what FAANG throws at the plebeians to milk them of their money ("caloric value"?). So yeah, now it makes sense: You've got your "valuable" and "not valuable" bass-ackwards; what you come off as valuing highly is the offal that the rich throw to the poor.
- cma 5y agoA third option with both funding and no artficial scarcity: https://cepr.net/report/the-artistic-freedom-voucher-internet-age-alternative-to-copyrights/ https://cepr.net/report/the-artistic-freedom-voucher-interne... Everyone gets money to spend as patrons for people contributing to the commons.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoWhat is artificial scarcity? I don’t disagree with funding arts, in fact I think that STEAM would be a superior system to STEM, but we don’t even fund STEM research enough today, even though many of the best scientists had artistic abilities: not full inference.
- cma 5y ago> What is artificial scarcity? The copyright system allows artificial scarcity to help fund things by restricting copies. But it doesn't have to be done that way.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoIn history it has been the most productive and innovative, because research and development takes time and money. The wright brothers are patent trolls who prevented the US from making plane designs, but without them we wouldn’t have modern flight. If we took away this incentive I doubt the world would be better. Currently you have this system where countries that don’t respect patents will just make it anyway, the US did against Europe and China does against the US. Asia did not have patents and Europeans did. If my ideas aren’t my own and anyone can copy it, I wouldn’t want to put efforts into something others will clone. I think patents are a necessary evil at least enough of it to make innovations, but foreign copycats and bootlegs serve this market well.
- CRConrad 5y ago> If my ideas aren’t my own and anyone can copy it, I wouldn’t want to put efforts into something others will clone. And yet, the FOSS movement persists.