3 ms·
The interesting conclusion from this is that if you are a crap-identifier you are not very valuable. i.e. a machine that calls everything crap is going to true-
by renewiltord 5y ago
The interesting conclusion from this is that if you are a crap-identifier you are not very valuable. i.e. a machine that calls everything crap is going to true-positive 90% of the time. So if you're like "That thing is crap" you are very similar to that machine, and maybe with some handwaving you are in the 90% for identifiers.
The hard part is to be the kind of person who can identify the 10% thing. It's even harder to be the kind of person who can offer the 10% thing.
In this way, mistake identifiers are low grade contributors.
- eesmith 5y agoThe conclusion is to use an appropriate classifier. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensitivity_and_specificity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensitivity_and_specificity even gives an analogous example: > Suppose a 'bogus' test kit is designed to always give a positive reading. When used on diseased patients, all patients test positive, giving the test 100% sensitivity. However, sensitivity does not take into account false positives. The bogus test also returns positive on all healthy patients, giving it a false positive rate of 100%, rendering it useless for detecting or "ruling in" the disease.
- xondono 5y agoI still prefer the “everything is crap” machine to the “everything is great” machine. Corollary: the only thing worse than a naysayer is a fanboy.
- renewiltord 5y agoInteresting. I find them both of low utility since they provide zero information but I do prefer encountering the fanboy because they are easy to detect: low base rate of good means “always good” will rapidly be erroneous, lowering detection time. Therefore, to me, fanboys are better. I quickly know I shouldn’t pay attention.
- xondono 5y agoI was thinking in investment terms, if you think everything is great, you’ll be out of money soon.