3 ms·
Great, now they should just stop using telephone numbers as identifiers.
by johnisgood 5y ago
Great, now they should just stop using telephone numbers as identifiers.
- maxwell 5y agoWhat do you suggest?
- sam_lowry_ 5y agoA login+password, like in IRC.
- tptacek 5y agoIRC tracks metadata serverside!
- johnisgood 5y agoI do not think that OP was referring to implementing it the same, or even in a similar way, but to use a username/password pair. OP is free to correct me if I am wrong though. In any case, elimination of metadata done right is the way Ricochet[1] does it. The recipient can calculate the sender's contact ID based on the public key, and authenticate it by verifying the signature on the request. This proves that the sender can publish the hidden service represented by their contact ID. You can read more about it here: https://github.com/ricochet-im/ricochet/blob/master/doc/design.md https://github.com/ricochet-im/ricochet/blob/master/doc/desi...! [1] https://github.com/ricochet-im/ricochet https://github.com/ricochet-im/ricochet (maintained fork: https://github.com/blueprint-freespeech/ricochet-refresh https://github.com/blueprint-freespeech/ricochet-refresh)
- zamadatix 5y agoSignal has had standard usernames on the roadmap for years.
- johnisgood 5y agoUsernames work. You could even use UUIDs these days as QR is an increasingly common way of sharing data. But yeah, usernames would be a great improvement.
- tptacek 5y agoUsernames do not just work. The Signal team is not unaware of usernames and Signal is not a weird scheme to get all your phone numbers. The difference between Signal and systems that use usernames (or email addresses) is that Signal deliberately doesn't operate a serverside directory or buddy list service. By contrast, other relatively popular messengers essentially keep a plaintext database of who talks to who on their service. What phone numbers allow Signal to do is to piggyback off the contact lists people already have on their devices.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kitkat_new 5y ago> is that Signal deliberately doesn't operate a serverside directory or buddy list service. how do people again discover each other on Signal most of the time? Anyways, nothing prevents Signal form creating it's own contact list within the app, perhaps bootstrapped from the existing one
- tptacek 5y agoThey can do that, but then when you switch devices, you lose your contact list. That's not what happens with the built-in contact list. This issue has been rehashed dozens of times on HN before (use the search bar below) and has basically nothing to do with the article.
- kitkat_new 5y agoactually, the contact list could include the signal identifiers
- XorNot 5y agoSignal uses phone numbers as identifiers because it controls spam. There's no reason - at all - they couldn't just throw the gates open and say "we hand out GUIDs per account and you do some auth process to tie them together to a master key" - but that's not why they're not implementing it. Signal without the phone number requirement becomes THE way to move data from anything to anything - malware would be written which setup a Signal account and used that for command and control. I'd wire all my service messages on servers to go via Signal - it's the perfect mechanism tied to the device I want them too. The answer is, Signal doesn't have a way to offer "usernames only" which wouldn't almost immediately explode the services usage far, far beyond what they can plausibly sustain in server costs. EDIT: Signal desperately need to figure out an actual monetization scheme for use-cases which do not need absolute privacy. Billing businesses for verified access to the service would be one way. Ideology and all is great, but if they can't pay the bills none of it is going to matter.
- johnisgood 5y agoCheck out https://github.com/ricochet-im/ricochet/blob/master/doc/protocol.md#contact-request-channel https://github.com/ricochet-im/ricochet/blob/master/doc/prot.... It is metadata-free. It does not require a centralized server. It uses Tor. Goals of the project (solved): Users aren't personally identifiable by contacts or their address Communication is authenticated and private No person or server can access contact lists, message history, or other metadata Resist censorship and monitoring at the local network level Resist blacklisting or denial of service against users Accessible and understandable for non-technical users Reliability and interactivity comparable with traditional IM services OK, the accessibility part is not implemented, but that is besides the point. I am not arguing in favor of using Ricochet here, so it does not matter anyways. FWIW, it has been audited.
- boogies 5y ago> The answer is, Signal doesn't have a way to offer "usernames only" which wouldn't almost immediately explode the services usage far, far beyond what they can plausibly sustain in server costs. Why can’t they let heavy users run their own servers?
- 5y ago