5 ms·
At some point I wonder if health insurers will start denying claims related to the treatment of COVID infections if the person is eligible for the vaccine but h
by criddell 5y ago
At some point I wonder if health insurers will start denying claims related to the treatment of COVID infections if the person is eligible for the vaccine but has refused to get one?
On TV today I saw that Kroger employees don't get sick day pay if they are off because of COVID unless they have been vaccinated (and I would assume there's a medical exemption).
- gjsman-1000 5y agoAccusations of Racism. Only 28% of young black people in New York are vaccinated as of October, for example. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/08/12/nyregion/covid-vaccine-black-young-new-yorkers.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/08/12/nyregion/covid-vaccine-bl... Edit: Added "young" adjective that was missing, point remains.
- chrisoverzero 5y ago> Only 28% of black people in New York are vaccinated […] This is not what the article you’ve cited says.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoWhoops - It said young (whatever that means) as an adjective. I'll edit that in.
- chrisoverzero 5y agoIt means 18 to 44, according to the article.
- klipklop 5y agoAKA working age people that will have to choose eventually between getting the vaccine and losing their job. A pretty rough choice for those hesitant. (I am vaccinated please don't post hot takes about how I am a anti-vaxer.)
- Karsteski 5y agoPlease don't overuse the word racism. Yes, a smaller percentage of black people in both the US and Canada are vaccinated. Yes they have very good reasons to be distrustful of government and institutions in general. It doesn't mean the vaccine distribution or enforcement is racist. I am very much against the forced vaccinations of people, and I very much abhor what is happening in Canada (where I live) with the vaccine passports and the making of the unvaccinated second class citizens. But don't make the term racism a worthless term by using it for everything. It's counterproductive. I say all this as a black Trinidadian immigrant that lives in Canada. I am vaccinated myself, but many black people I know are not.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoI am not going to state here whether I think it would or would not be racist. I am saying though, that if you unilaterally denied COVID care to non-vaccinated patients, that would be the equivalent of denying service to ~70% of "young black people," which would be easy bait for people calling that racist. Which is why the health system probably won't do it.
- Karsteski 5y agoI understand what you're saying actually. I mean, if that hinders the enforcement of vaccination to exist in society, then I'm on board I guess. Even if I would prefer if people got vaccinated.
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoAh yeah, anti-vaxxers (I'm not calling you one) grasping at straws including calling the vax mandates racist because of the low vax uptake from Black people. If it was a policy that's based on something that the Black people can't change about them (e.g. refusal to entry to a club based on your address, with majority black areas of town being in that list), and it disadvantages them, yes that'd be racist. But in this case, the Black people (or whoever) can easily change it by getting vaxed...
- Karsteski 5y agoIt's important to keep in mind that black people have very many reasons to distrust government.
- ethbr0 5y agoRacism by intent and racism by outcome are both racism. Regarding the latter, it's not difficult to create a policy that's non-racist in construction, but has reliably racist results. Correlated parameters, etc. Whether anything can or should be done about it is a thornier question.
- solididiot 5y agoIn my country (EU) COVID incidents get handled by public health system only. Which was not in great shape to begin with. Health insurers had bailed out since day zero on COVID. There's lately though talk about unvaccinated COVID patients bearing the cost nonetheless. Note that public health system is for free.
- Radim 5y ago> Note that public health system is for free. In my country (also EU) the public health system is most definitely not "free". It is paid for by a universal tax called (insidiously and inaccurately) "health insurance". > There's lately though talk about unvaccinated COVID patients bearing the cost nonetheless. Calls for true insurance (individualized, based on actual health and habits) are completely infeasible for political reasons. What I can see happening is the existing mandatory health tax PLUS extra payments for non-grata groups. Some constitutional changes may be needed, but since all the right people would profit (extra $$$), that's just a technical detail in this day and age.
- solididiot 5y agoI'm not sure I follow you but a few things are apparent to me at 45 yrs of age: 1. public health system will take care of you to its abilities (which to a large extent are defined by the taxation yes) 2. no private insurer is paying or covering anything COVID-related and they never did 3. been trying to get private insurance on top of the public one and I'm told time and again that a few systems of mine will be excluded (i.e. they won't insure me for anything bearing the remotest possibility of actually needing them for). Also that I am too old to start now... if anything is clear from the COVID story in my mind is that we need a better and more capable public health system. Private healthcare is not about health or care.
- chernevik 5y agoBy that logic insurers could deny claims related to obesity, or risky sexual behavior. Would you approve of that?
- stareblinkstare 5y agoSome of us gladly would.
- stefan_ 5y agoTry getting a liver transplant without sobriety.
- refurb 5y agoSure, but everything up to that point gets paid for happily.
- radnor 5y agoIt is not possible to spread obesity or risky sexual behavior to others.
- refurb 5y agoIrrelevant? Personal choice = costs to others. Isn’t that the argument?
- azth 5y agoNot true. It's trivial to spread immorality and normalize it which would lead to risky sexual behavior. We're literally living through it now. Just look at how things slid in the past 100 years on that front.
- pseudo0 5y agoPeople who engage in risky sexual behavior increase the spread of STDs in the population as a whole, causing increased risk even for those who don't engage in risky sexual behavior. The parallels to COVID seem pretty clear, no?
- 5y ago
- ekianjo 5y ago> if health insurers will start denying claims related to the treatment of COVID infections Will health insurers deny claims related to cancer if you have been drinking alcohol? Good luck living in that world.
- ASalazarMX 5y agoHealth insurers want to increase, or at least maintain, their profits. They won't deny claims because they want a better society, they want to minimize their financial risk. So yes, one would expect to be in their commercial interest to deny cancer claims to people who willingly put themselves at excessive risk of cancer at some point in the future. It's the infinite wisdom of the free market!
- belltaco 5y agoQuitting alcohol is nowhere as easy as getting covid vaccines. If there was a cheap/free safe vaccine that reduced the chances of getting hospitalized or dying of cancer by >60%, your point would be more valid.
- azth 5y agoThe difference is that it's a choice to get addicted to alcohol.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoThey are clearly not the same, but you first have to make the claim that insurance coverage should be tied to ease of prevention at all, before arguing where the line should be. I'm not aware of any other risky behaviors that exclude coverage, so this would be a precedent.
- criddell 5y agoI've since come around and now think they wouldn't exclude coverage, but they might charge a different premium. That seems fair.
- disambiguation 5y agoBut isn't that the point of insurance? You pay in some money to offset the risk of an unlikely yet massive expense? What's special about covid versus other risky activities that individuals can take action to offset? Even something as horribly negligent as drunk-driving is handled by insurance. So are drug overdoses. IMO this sentiment is just another manifestation of the overwhelming desire to punish the unvaccinated, rather than being based on clear thinking.
- criddell 5y agoIf you have a drunk driving conviction, your insurance rates are going to go way up. If you are a drug addict, your life insurance premiums will be very high. I suppose the appropriate response to people who choose to not get vaccinated would be to pay a higher premium to account for the extra risk.
- shadowgovt 5y agoUsually, insurance companies do this carrot-style, not stick-style (i.e. they will give you a premiums discount of some kind if you get a COVID vaccine, or possibly even a one-off gift like a gift card or toaster or something). ... but yes, they definitely already do similar things to influence customer behavior (such as discounts on weight loss programs).
- bananapear 5y agoBUPA (UK private health insurer) isn't covering treatment for conditions caused by the vaccine: https://twitter.com/bupauk/status/1368841967086473216 https://twitter.com/bupauk/status/1368841967086473216 https://pbs.twimg.com/media/ExeyKpEW8AEDAdg?format=jpg&name=small https://pbs.twimg.com/media/ExeyKpEW8AEDAdg?format=jpg&name=...