2 ms·
When a post lowers the quality of the debate. > I believe that downvoting someone just because you disagree with them is terrible for a discussion network like
by mdp2021 5y ago
When a post lowers the quality of the debate.
> I believe that downvoting someone just because you disagree with them is terrible for a discussion network like HN
Yes: that would be unintellectual. If this is for debate, debate it should be. (Otherwise it would be "polling", not debating.)
Some noted that "If one can upvote to express agreement, then one could downvote to express disagreement". This position fails to see the asymmetry in rational discourse: you may not need further arguments to support the weight of an expressed position, but you do, in general, need arguments to instead oppose it.
(Otherwise, it's Monty Python's Argument Sketch - "Yes it is", "No it isn't"...)