2 ms·
> I would gladly hop in a better car, if the newer car has less features and is worst, I will not. The ecosystem around bicycles is much better than the ecosys
by dijit 5y ago
> I would gladly hop in a better car, if the newer car has less features and is worst, I will not.
The ecosystem around bicycles is much better than the ecosystem around trucks.
You are tasked with getting to and from work every day, in the beginning it's just you who travels, but over time you have more and more things to carry with you- shovels and such.
You buy a trailer.
You find that with your trailer it's more difficult to see what is coming up behind you, so you buy side mirrors.
You find that in the cold it's difficult to keep your hands warm, so you buy hand warmers, and lights on a dynamo.
Eventually your bike is quite heavy, you carry much and requires much more effort to operate.
But it has a lot of "features".
This is the sunk cost fallacy in action.
> Do you love broken userspace? That's great, choose a compositor that breaks your userspace? My mentality of having robust software is the opposite. Suprise!
My userspace is absolutely not broken. Arguably it's less broken than yours but you've patched around the issues or are blind to them.
Sway crashes for me less often than Xorg did; but I understand that Xorg and Wayland are not the same, and that took some getting used to, and indeed it was uncomfortable in the beginning.
You are passionately arguing from a place of absolute ignorance, I have used both. I have used both professionally. I have used both for years.
Yes, I replaced a lot of my normal programs.
Yes, Wayland has issues, many of which could have been addressed if people weren't conservative. Not that I begrudge them for it, I believe choice is good.
But, it's absolutely ignorant to claim that X11 has features. X11 does not have features, it has people willing to hack on it and an architecture that allows disgusting and ugly hacks to work.
You might like that, I absolutely despise it- because malicious software exists (and I use it), things like Zoom which if given the opportunity would love to run as root and capture all my keystrokes.
Things like Teams which on Android devices managed to block 911 calls.
Things like Chrome which is attempting to be my userland.
Ultimately, I trust my windowing system more than I trust random programs I may run to bind my hotkeys.
> I'll end by saying wayland is fundamentally broken.
Wayland is not "fundamentally broken" it's been working for me professionally for years. The "features" you cite so often are non-features "my cursor can change color!" which are not inherent in x.org at all.
Wayland "breaks" things that are designed to work exclusively with X11. Much like how graphics cards "break things" that are designed to work on a serial console.
I must conclude that you're a troll. Honestly.
- GhettoComputers 5y ago> Yes, Wayland has issues, many of which could have been addressed if people weren't conservative. Not that I begrudge them for it, I believe choice is good. Them the developers should do something about it, instead of calling a comparatively crippled compositor complete. If choice is good, respect everyone who says x.org is better, instead of trying to scare drums or use vague words like “progress”. Progress towards what? Lower Linux satisfaction? If you think I’m a troll because I refuse to lie about how the useless wayland is actually good and don’t engage in an encho chamber of praise, you need to listen to complaints and respect opinions of others. Your analogy is of it being a truck instead of a bike, it’s hard to take you seriously unless you’re trolling, that is unless it’s a plastic toy truck. You bring up nonexistent threats like Android not calling 911, and demonstrate it’s being a no threat, and an irrelevant threat. Don’t joyfully call everyone to switch from fine software and enjoy their new crippled and child proof space progress and applause the broken userspace for the sake of scaling, slightly smoother movements and colored cursors. Respect other people who don’t like the same thing you do instead of calling them wrong. You wouldn’t do this to a sexual preference, not Thor compositor.
- dijit 5y agoWhat is "crippled"? That you can't steal keystrokes from other programs? Screensharing? (which is an adoption issue for clients, not a "problem" with Wayland) Your X11 programs (not hacks) already work as if they were X11 with Xwayland, but it has the same drawbacks as running it natively with X11. (with a small bonus that it's rootless... unlike X11 which is assuredly not rootless by default). Do you honestly believe that wayland developers should reimplement all software that has leveraged and abused the X11 system? Seems asinine, what are your _real needs_ that Wayland isn't providing support for?
- AshamedCaptain 5y agoYou call it "hacks and abuses", but it's actually extensibility. Which Wayland kind of lacks (you need support for all of this in the compositor, rather than 3rd party processes being able to provide it). > Do you honestly believe that wayland developers should reimplement all software that has leveraged and abused the X11 system? Most definitely not, but what they should do is just to _allow_ the continued existence of all the software which has leveraged X11 in their garden, if the garden is to have any kind of success. And not as 2nd grade citizens.