6 ms·
> Massive battery installations plus solar are already cheaper than operating an existing natural gas peaker plant in California Aren't natural gas prices pret
by sofixa 5y ago
> Massive battery installations plus solar are already cheaper than operating an existing natural gas peaker plant in California
Aren't natural gas prices pretty high currently ? And with many countries moving away from gas in their electricity production, or at least moving it to peak-only, the price will go down.
Furthermore, batteries with what capacity? I highly doubt they're of the size required to sustain multi-week storm/bad weather events, even for the rarity they'd be in sunny California, le alone the rest of the US.
And from a globally strategic point of view, isn't it better to focus battery capacity on decarbonising sectors such as transportation ( cars, trucks, even trains apparently ( i still think electrifying the network is a better idea overall, but i can see how it'd be cheaper upfront to just add a battery car)) instead of "wasting" TWhs of battery capacity for long term storage.
- tailsdog 5y ago> And with many countries moving away from gas in their electricity production, or at least moving it to peak-only, the price will go down. If there is less consumption I would imagine the price would rather go up.
- irrational 5y agoThis was my thought too. I hope OP responds with why they think lessened demand would lead to lower prices. That doesn’t make any sense.
- ovi256 5y agoIt's a consequence of a demand curve: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demand_curve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demand_curve, an established concept in economics
- nindalf 5y agoIt’s unclear to me if that accounts for second order effects? For example, lower demand leads to lower prices, sure. But then those lower prices lead to higher demand. This should quickly reach equilibrium if buying and selling were spur of the moment decisions with no long term consequence. But in the energy market that’s not the case. Building a power plant is a commitment to buying that product, which locks in that demand regardless of price. And so continued low prices could lead to more construction of gas plants, which leads to an increase in demand. Basically what I’m saying is that the demand curve models a simple market with a fungible good, which can be bought and sold easily. We have to recognise that it’s like studying spherical, frictionless projectiles in physics. A good starting point, but not how the real world works.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago>For example, lower demand leads to lower prices, sure. But then those lower prices lead to higher demand. Supply curve is missing in these statements. > Building a power plant is a commitment to buying that product, which locks in that demand regardless of price. What? Is there some sort of law that requires buyers to buy all of the electricity a power plant can produces? > And so continued low prices could lead to more construction of gas plants, which leads to an increase in demand. This is backwards. An increase in demand for electricity might lead to construction of new gas plants, with a bet that even with the increased supply, electricity buyers are willing to pay at least x price for electricity for y duration sufficient to earn a z return on investment for building the new gas plant.
- ovi256 5y agoThat would happen if supply goes down even more. Is this the case here ?
- jhgb 5y agoNormally if nothing else changed you'd expect prices to go down since the most expensive providers (= those with highest costs of doing their business) pulling the price up leave the market.
- hutzlibu 5y ago" I highly doubt they're of the size required to sustain multi-week storm/bad weather events" Those bad weather events come usually with lots of wind - which you can harvest, too. So the solution might just be the often propagated energy mix. And you can build batteries without any rare elements(natrium instead of lithium), so if you build enough of them and enough solar and co. then who cares if some of that energy gets lost, as long as the grid remains stable?
- sofixa 5y ago> Those bad weather events come usually with lots of wind - which you can harvest, too. So the solution might just be the often propagated energy mix. As i have said a few times around here, there's a meteorological phenomenon across Europe now ( since September, and projected to go well into the winter), with bad weather ( clouds, low sunlight), low temperatures, and low wind speeds. Traditional hydro and tidal energy generation are still OK, but solar and wind are at historical lows. And again, this is ongoing for months. Furthermore, a bad weather event like storms can have winds that are too fast for a wind generator to operate safely.
- hutzlibu 5y agoWell, I know that, because I have to sustain that lack of sun and wind here, too. But the south(west) of europe still has lots of sun, like it almost always has. And a bit further south, there is always sun in the desert. So yes, I would not deconstruct all the conventional power plants, just yet. And I think having some backup gas plants is not a bad idea, either.
- cedilla 5y agoAt least for Germany, that's just not the case. Wind is going quite strong this quarter, so strong that it easily offsets the lower-than-average solar generation. And that's mostly due to the weather – expansion was massively stalled by conservative administrations in the last few years.
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoI hear a lot about replacing gas with hydrogen (completely doable with the existing infrastructure).
- unpolloloco 5y agoWhich is effectively a battery! Hydrogen production is energy intensive, but if you produce it with excess energy capacity and then use it when it's needed, it's a decent energy storage method. Though mobile applications (air travel, trains, etc) are more likely to dominate in the shorter terms as it's lighter than batteries in high power applications
- bell-cot 5y agoAny particular sources? From a quick web search, it sounds like hydrogen has a very different energy density (Joules/cu. m., or BTU/cu. ft., or whatever), very different combustion and leak safety characteristics, and can either leak through or embrittle many parts of the existing (natural gas) distribution infrastructure. If that's anything resembling correct...then the change-over would be more like replacing all-diesel fuel & engine infrastructure with gasoline.
- pydry 5y agoThis is the oil/gas industry trying to keep themselves relevant. Thats why we keep hearing abouti it. Hydrogen can be cheap (extracted from natural gas) or green (electrolysis). It can't be both. Hydrogen is also a monumental PITA to store.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoGreen hydrogen can be cheap if electricity is cheap. With the falling prices of renewables, that is quite likely to happen soon. But green hydrogen is only useful if electricity is cheap but batteries are expensive. The original article indicates why batteries aren't expensive and are likely to get dramatically cheaper over the next decade. That's why hydrogen is likely to stay irrelevant except for niche use cases.
- 5y ago
- bryanlarsen 5y agoNatural gas prices in California are dominated by transport costs, not production costs. To survive a multi-week storm/bad weather event with a grid containing only solar and wind, you need a 3x overbuild of solar+wind in an optimal mix, along with a continental grid and 3 hours worth of batteries is all you need for 99.99% reliability: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-26355-z https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-26355-z
- seoaeu 5y ago> containing only solar and wind Conveniently leaving out hydro and nuclear… [Edit: which only makes this easier.]
- cedilla 5y agoNuclear isn't sustainable, extremely slow to build and astronomically expensive. It's not an option. Hydropower is sustainable but has a very limited potential,and its impact on the environment is much, much higher than comparable wind/solar installations.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoThe big advantage of nuclear is that it is reliable. However, the paper I linked above says wind and solar can be reliable, so nuclear no longer has any redeeming qualities.
- dangoor 5y agoThe abstract for the paper (thanks for that link!) says: > Yet even in systems which meet >90% of demand, hundreds of hours of unmet demand may occur annually. ... and the low end of the range is 72%, which leaves many more hours unaccounted for. Some amount of reliable, clean power is needed on top of the renewables.
- bryanlarsen 5y ago