4 ms·
"the free market works well" Unless there is too much inflation like in Weimar Republic, too much corruption like in Russia, too much monopoly like with Standa
by ClumsyPilot 5y ago
"the free market works well"
Unless there is too much inflation like in Weimar Republic, too much corruption like in Russia, too much monopoly like with Standard Oil, too many shenanigans leading to 2008-style meltdown (imagine that without central bank support), given working police and the justice system which is missing in many developing countries, given basic infrastructure like roads and electricity etc, etc.
- WalterBright 5y ago> Unless there is too much inflation like in Weimar Republic The government money printing press is not free market. > too much corruption like in Russia The government's role in a free market is to prevent corruption. > too much monopoly like with Standard Oil Standard Oil was very good for consumers, as SO brought about something like a 70% reduction in kerosene prices. Besides, SO never was a monopoly. It was accused of attempting to create one. > imagine that without central bank support Don't need to imagine it. It happened several times in the 1800s. Recovery tended to be as quick. > given working police and the justice system Free markets require a working police and justice system
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"The government money printing press is not free market." Oh no, not again this 'No True Scottman'-'Free market' myth. Let's go down this path - what does 'free market' theory say, how much money should be in the economy? How should it be created or destroyed? There is no natural process for it, whoever has lisense to print money can rule the world or collapse the economy. 'Free market theory' provides no answer, just like it provides no answer to most important economic questions. Is using a physical valuable substance as money, let's say gold, free market? That's Mercantilism and it brought national economies to a standstill due to lack of liquidity. People couldn't trade goods, take loans, nations went to wars over silver. Do you want to have gold standard and fractional reserve banking? Is it freely floating currency and a system where banks create money out of thin air? (governments don't print money any more by the way). Which one of these three totally different systems is the mythical true 'free market'? Are private currencies owned by banks free market? That's what we used to have, they used to collapse all the time. That's why we invented central banks.
- WalterBright 5y ago> how much money should be in the economy? How should it be created or destroyed? Great questions. Money is created when money is loaned out against collateral. Money is destroyed when the loan is repaid and the collateral returned. It's a natural process. The pressure on it is to have the supply of money match the value in the collateral. > whoever has lisense to print money Under a free banking system, anyone can print money. Of course, anyone printing money has to convince others that it has value. Did you know that anyone can print money today? We call them "IOUs", "checks", and more recently, "credit cards". We're all familiar with having to convince others that our IOUs, checks, and credit cards will be honored. I'm not aware of any that managed to rule the world or collapse the economy. > no answer I just gave you one! I can only surmise you've been talking to the wrong people. May I suggest Milton Friedman's "Monetary History of the United States". It's tough sledding, but worth it if you really want to know. > Is using a physical valuable substance as money, let's say gold, free market? Of course. Are you familiar with the commodities marketplace? It's the same thing, but would you call that mercantilism? Shipping gold around to settle debts, however, is clumsy, expensive, and dangerous, hence the rise of trading receipts for the gold instead, and later those receipts turning into bank notes, and even later became electronic entries in a ledger. > Do you want to have gold standard and fractional reserve banking? That's how free banking worked in the United States. It's free market. > they used to collapse all the time. Not all the time, but banks did fail from time to time. > That's why we invented central banks. That was the public reason. The real reason was to inflate the money. As for collapse, now we have fewer bank failures, but when they do fail, it's a doozy (Great Depression, 2008, etc.). Also, did you notice that as of this month 9% of the money you had last year disappeared? You can thank our fiat money system for that. I grew up in the Carter stagflation years, and learned to never keep more than pocket money around. It's all in things that aren't inflated into worthlessness by the central bank. P.S. How do I know all this stuff? My dad spent the last years of his career as head of the finance department at a college. We had many long and happy conversations about how banks worked. It isn't an easy subject, but I wish more people could have such an experience.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"Money is created when money is loaned out against collateral. Money is destroyed when the loan is repaid and the collateral returned. It's a natural process." But there is nothing natural about it - the limit on money supply is how easy it is to get a loan. Bank could give out mortgages with 0% deposit, they could give out loans equal to 120% of the house value, and they indeed have done so. What regulates the money supply is not 'natural process' but the rules set by the regylator on minimum reguirements. Is having no rules free market? But then it will be creating 2008 style event every tuesday. Furthermore, this whole thing only creates money in our current floating-money system, right? If you have medieval-style economy where you count literal gold coins, you can not create money, you would just be loaning out other people's deposits. The amount of money in the system would stay fixed, right? So then the only 'natural' money supply is your ability to mine gold?
- Sebb767 5y agoIt's definitely fair game to critique capitalism and free matkets based on actual implementations, not theoretical optimized scenarios. If we're going for perfect scenario, communism is absolutely a great idea. Unfortunately, the real world is a bit different, and it turns out that capitalism and free markets can survive reality and bad actors just a bit better. And that's what counts in the end. Still, we shouldn't dismiss the failures of the system, since this is what shows misaligned incentives.